Explain what happened to the pound on 16 September 1992, what led up to it, and how far the pound fell afterwards.
11 min
7 questions
On 16 September 1992 the pound opened just above its lowest allowed rate
By 8 o'clock on the morning of Wednesday 16 September 1992, a pound bought 2.7794 German marks. Britain was in the European exchange rate mechanism (ERM), which held each currency near a fixed rate against the others. For the pound, the lower limit was 2.7780 marks. By the evening Britain had left, and Members of Parliament were soon calling the day black Wednesday. Britain never rejoined, and it kept the pound when most of the EU moved to the euro in 1999.
Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
How did the pressure on the pound build before 16 September 1992?
What happened on 16 September 1992?
How far did the pound fall, and what did trying to hold it up cost?
Take a guess
Britain had chosen to tie the pound to the other European currencies. What do you think the government said it joined for?
The Prime Minister later told the House of Commons that Britain joined to help bring inflation down. The next section says how membership went.
Where this sits
Black Wednesday · this module is lit
8 Oct 1990Britain joins the European exchange rate mechanism (ERM), which holds member currencies within set limits of each other
2 Jun 1992Danish voters reject the Maastricht Treaty, the agreement on a single European currency
16 Jul 1992The Bundesbank, Germany's central bank, raises one of its official interest rates
3 Sep 1992The British government announces it will borrow foreign currency worth ten billion ECU, the European Community's own currency unit
13 Sep 1992The Italian lira's fixed rate in the ERM is lowered
16 Sep 1992Black Wednesday: after a day defending the pound, Britain suspends its membership of the ERM
24 Sep 1992Parliament is recalled to debate economic policy
Oct 1992The Chancellor of the Exchequer, the minister in charge of tax and spending, sets out a new framework for monetary policy, the setting of interest rates to steer inflation
26 Jan 1993Base rates, the rates banks charge, reach 6 per cent
Britain joined the mechanism in October 1990
The Prime Minister, John Major, later told the House of Commons why Britain had joined: to help bring down inflation. Base rates are the interest rates the high-street banks charge. While Britain was a member, base rates came down from 15 to 10 per cent, the Prime Minister said. By August 1992, retail prices were rising at 3.6 per cent a year.
The fixed rates could be changed, but only if all the members agreed. A reset of the fixed rates is a realignment. A realignment could lower one currency's fixed rate against the rest. Lowering a currency's fixed rate in this way is a devaluation.
Pressure on the pound built through the summer of 1992
On 2 June 1992 voters in Denmark rejected the Maastricht Treaty, the European agreement that included a plan for a single currency. A currency is under pressure when many traders want to sell it. The heads of the European Community's central banks later reported that the currency markets changed sharply after the Danish vote. In their account, the Italian lira was under the most pressure. The pound stayed close to its lower limit. France was to vote on the same treaty on 20 September.
On 3 September the British government announced that it would borrow foreign currency worth ten billion ECU. The ECU was the European Community's own currency unit. A week later, in Glasgow, John Major said the Chancellor had already made one thing clear: "there is going to be no devaluation, no realignment".
Check yourself
The government borrowed foreign currency in September 1992, not pounds. How was that money meant to help the pound?
The lira was devalued and Germany cut its rates
On 13 September the members lowered the lira's fixed rate and raised every other currency's, the pound's included. Each move was 3.5 per cent. Together, the two moves left the lira about 7 per cent lower against the rest. On 14 September the Bundesbank, Germany's central bank, cut its interest rates by less than some in the markets expected.
The next day the pound fell and closed at 2.7812 marks. Reports that evening said the Bundesbank's President had told a newspaper it would have been better to lower the fixed rates of more currencies, not just the lira's. The Bundesbank denied them.
At its lower limit, a member had to buy its own currency in unlimited amounts, the Chancellor later told the Commons. Traders betting on the pound falling borrowed pounds and sold them. Higher interest rates made that borrowing cost more, the Bank of England noted.
Take a guess
On the morning of 16 September the pound was just above its lower limit. How high do you think the government said it would take interest rates that day?
The answer is 15 per cent, in two steps. A first rise, to 12 per cent, took effect. The second rise was announced but never applied. The next section takes the day hour by hour.
Through the day the Bank of England defended the pound
In the hour after 8 o'clock that Wednesday the Bank of England bought pounds very heavily, paying with other currencies. The Bundesbank and the Banque de France, France's central bank, helped. The Bank of England has its own interest rate, the minimum lending rate. High-street banks set their base rates to follow it. At 11 o'clock the Bank set its minimum lending rate at 12 per cent, two points above where base rates had been. The high-street banks raised their base rates to match. The pound stayed at its limit.
At 2.15 pm the Bank announced a second rise in its minimum lending rate, to 15 per cent from the next day. This time the banks did not change their base rates. When the European exchange markets closed, the pound was still at its limit.
That evening Britain left the mechanism
The Chancellor of the Exchequer is the minister in charge of tax and spending. In 1992 he was Norman Lamont. Just after 7.30 pm he announced that Britain was suspending its membership of the ERM. He also cancelled the second rise. At 9.30 the next morning the Bank cut its minimum lending rate back to where base rates had been. The banks cut their base rates too. The same night Italy's central bank stopped buying lira to support it. Spain's currency, the peseta, was devalued by 5 per cent.
Check yourself
The Bank paid for the pounds it bought with marks and other currencies it held. If the pound then fell, what happened to the value of the pounds it had bought?
Outside the mechanism, the pound fell
With no limit to hold it, the pound fell. On 18 September it closed at 2.6100 marks, 6 per cent below its old limit. On 5 October it reached 2.3709 marks. After that it rose again, to around 2.50 marks. The central bank governors reported that by the end of 1992 the pound was 13 per cent lower against the mark than on Black Wednesday. On the chart's monthly averages, a pound bought about 2.81 marks in August 1992 and about 2.45 marks in October.
The chart shows the pound's average value in marks each month, from January 1992 to the end of 1994. In the first half of 1992, while Britain was a member, that average was between about 2.86 and 2.93 marks.
The pound in German marks, 1992 to 1994Marks per pound, monthly average
Source: IMF Exchange Rates dataset: German marks per dollar times dollars per pound, monthly averages. IMF data, used with credit.
Check yourself
Look at the chart. By the end of 1994, did the pound's monthly average ever get back to the level it held in the first half of 1992, while Britain was a member?
The Treasury later counted the cost
The Treasury is the government department for tax and spending. Black Wednesday cost 3.3 billion pounds, by the Treasury's own estimate. That estimate is in an internal Treasury note written in 1997 and released in 2005.
Within a week of John Major ruling out a devaluation in Glasgow, Britain had left the mechanism. The Bank of England bought pounds heavily, raised interest rates once and announced a second rise. Why was that not enough to keep Britain in? And what did Britain do after it left? The next module takes up both questions.
Check yourself
Work from two rates given above: 2.7794 marks at 8 am on 16 September, and 2.3709 marks on 5 October. Roughly what percentage of its value against the mark had the pound lost?
%
15 %
About 15 per cent: 2.3709 divided by 2.7794 is about 0.85, a fall of about 14.7 per cent in less than three weeks.
Check yourself
The key questions
How did the pressure on the pound build before 16 September 1992?
After Denmark voted against the Maastricht Treaty in June, the lira came under the most pressure. The pound sat near its limit. The government borrowed foreign currency to buy pounds with, and ruled out devaluation. Even so, the lira was devalued on 13 September, and two days later the pound fell again.
What happened on 16 September 1992?
The Bank of England bought pounds heavily. It set its lending rate at 12 per cent, two points above where base rates had been. Then it announced a second rise. The pound stayed at its limit. That evening Britain suspended its membership and cancelled the second rise.
How far did the pound fall, and what did trying to hold it up cost?
After Britain left the mechanism, the pound fell sharply against the mark within three weeks. The central bank governors reported that at the end of 1992 it was still well below its level on Black Wednesday. The Treasury later put the cost of Black Wednesday at billions of pounds.
The numbers
The lowest rate the ERM allowed the pound against the mark2.7780 marks
The pound at the close on 18 September 1992 (daily rate)2.6100 marks
The pound on 5 October 1992 (daily rate)2.3709 marks
Fall against the mark, 16 September to the end of 1992 (central bank governors)13 per cent
The Treasury's 1997 estimate of the loss, on its preferred assumptions, measured at February 19943.3 billion pounds
Check yourself
Think over June to the evening of 15 September 1992. Which of these best describes where the pound stood by then?
Check yourself
Which of these matches what happened on 16 September 1992?
Check yourself
A family changed £500 into marks for a holiday. Using the monthly averages above, about how many fewer marks did they get in October 1992 than they would have in August?