Learn › Economic history › The Great Depression

The Great Depression

Unemployment and Hardship in the Depression

Who paid for it

Eight steps, about twelve minutes, a question at each. You need no economics and no preparation, only a willingness to guess before you are told.

Step 1 of 8

The question

Losing your job was the damage everyone could see. People who kept their jobs lost money too, and a drought hit the farms. Almost nobody was measuring any of it.

President Herbert Hoover did act against the Depression. He put $1.5 billion into public works, which are roads, dams and buildings paid for by the government. In January 1932 he also set up a government lender. Both were far too small for a collapse of this size. A drought also hit the farming states of the Great Plains through the 1930s. Farming families lost their living, and no government policy had caused it.

What you'll be able to answer

  1. Why did Hoover's response not stop the fall?
  2. Did the people who kept their jobs escape the Depression?
  3. Why did the hardship last a decade rather than a few years?
  4. Why do the unemployment figures for the 1930s differ?
Where this sits in the series

The Great Depression Β· this module is lit

  1. 1928The Federal Reserve starts raising interest rates
  2. Aug 1929The American economy stops growing
  3. Oct 1929The Wall Street crash
  4. Jun 1930America raises its tariffs
  5. Nov 1930The first wave of bank failures
  6. Sep 1931Britain leaves gold
  7. Mar 1933Every bank shut; the fall ends; the New Deal begins
  8. 1933Unemployment at its worst
  9. May 1937A second fall begins
  10. 1942 to 1943War production closes the gap
Why it matters and what it covers

The unemployment rate is the figure quoted most often for the 1930s. It leaves out much of the damage. Between 1929 and 1933 the pay of American factory workers fell sharply for every hour worked. Their working week was cut as well. So people who stayed in work still lost a large part of what they earned.

Nobody measured these losses at the time. The United States had no figure for what the whole country earned in a year. A senator ordered one in 1932, and it arrived in January 1934. The pensions law of 1935 did not cover farm workers or people paid to work in other people's homes. The unemployment figures quoted today for the 1930s were built by the Bureau of Labor Statistics in 1945, six years after the decade ended.

Eight steps on who carried the cost, and why it is so hard to see.

Step 1 · 1932

The government acted, but far too little

Take a guess

Hoover put $1.5 billion into public works and built a government lender. Why is he still remembered as the president who did nothing?

An economy that shrinks sharply needs somebody to get it growing again. The question is who does it, and with how much money.

President Herbert Hoover put $1.5 billion into public works. He also set up a government lender. The economy kept falling.

Public works are roads, dams and buildings paid for by the government so that people have work.

The lender was the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, set up on 22 January 1932 to lend to banks, railways and other companies in trouble.

Hoover is remembered as the president who did nothing. In fact the record shows him taking several large steps.

For scaleThe Reconstruction Finance Corporation was established on 22 January 1932.

Step 2 · through the 1930s

A drought as well

Take a guess

No government caused the drought, and no government could end it. So why did it make the Depression worse?

A drought hit the farming land of the middle United States through the 1930s. Farming families lost their living, and no government policy had caused it.

The drought was at its most severe across the southwestern Great Plains, the wide flat farming land in the middle of the country.

Dry conditions ran from the Appalachian mountains in the east to the Rocky Mountains in the west.

Farming families with no income could not buy goods, so the people who sold to them lost sales too. No government policy could end the drought.

For scaleThe drought lasted through the 1930s. Sources disagree about which year it began.

Step 3 · 1929 to 1933

Pay and hours fell as well as jobs

Between 1929 and 1933 the pay of American factory workers fell by 21.4 per cent an hour.

Their weekly hours fell as well, by 13.8 per cent over the same years. Many workers who kept a job were put on short time. Short time means fewer hours, and so a smaller wage.

A third figure is total wage income: all the wages paid to the people who kept their jobs, added together.

Having a job in 1933 did not mean earning what you earned before. The unemployment figure on its own does not show this.

Hourly pay fell 21.4 per cent. For people who kept their jobs, how far did total wage income fall?

US wages and salaries, 1929 to 1939Billions of dollars, not adjusted for changes in prices. One figure a year.
0204060192919311933193519371939Lowest, 1933

Source: US Bureau of Economic Analysis, Gross domestic income: Compensation of employees, paid: Wages and salaries (A4102C1A027NBEA), via FRED

For scaleAverage weekly hours fell 13.8 per cent over the same four years.

Step 4 · 1929 to 1934

What the government could see

When the Great Depression began in 1929, the American government could see much less of its own economy than a government can see today.

The total every person in a country earns in a year is its . A government that has that total can say how much smaller the country has become.

In 1930 the government took a census, a count of the whole population. People said at once that its figures were too low.

Congress, the body that makes America's laws, was unhappy with the 1930 count. It ordered a second, special count for January 1931.

national income
The total value of everything a country produces in a year. Government figures are usually given as a share of it, because that is what makes a sum comparable between one decade and another.
unemployment
The number of people who want paid work and cannot find it, usually given as a share of all those working or looking for work. People who are not looking are not counted, so the figure understates how many are out of work.

It is 1930. The government could do three of these things. Which one could it not do?

For scaleThe 1930 census unemployment figures were attacked as being too low.

Step 5 · 1932

You are a United States senator

In 1932 the American government had no way to measure how much poorer the country had become. You are the senator who must decide whether to order that measurement.

Banks are closing and farms are failing, and the 1930 census figures on work have already been attacked as too low. You can read what one industry says about itself, and nothing about the country.

Ordering a national income report would take a Senate Resolution, which is a formal vote of the Senate. Building the figure would take a team under an economist such as Simon Kuznets, about two years, and money.

National income statisticsnone existNo total for what the country earns in a year, so the size of the fall cannot be stated.
Unemploymentthe 1930 count was disputedThe census figures were attacked as too low and Congress ordered a second count for January 1931.
Payno national seriesWages were known for each industry, but there was no figure for the whole country.
Hours workedno national seriesThere was no figure for the hours worked across the whole country. A worker put on short time still looked like a worker with a job.
Public works spending$1.5 billionPresident Hoover put $1.5 billion into roads, dams and buildings, and the economy kept falling. He also set up a government lender on 22 January 1932.

You are Senator Robert La Follette in 1932. The government cannot tell you how much poorer America has become. What do you do?

Step 6 · 1935

Who the 1935 law left out

The Social Security Act of 1935, which set up American state pensions and unemployment payments, did not cover farm workers or domestic servants.

Domestic service means paid work in somebody else's home. The people who wrote the law had only the 1930 census to show what jobs people did. In that census, about 65 per cent of black Americans with jobs were farm workers or domestic servants.

About 27 per cent of white Americans in work had the same kinds of job, so the same rule left them out too.

The rule listed jobs and never named a race. It still left out about 65 per cent of black workers.

The 1935 law left out farm workers and domestic servants. Of all the workers it left out, which group had the most people?

For scaleAbout 65 per cent of black Americans in work were in farm work or domestic service, on the 1930 census.

Step 7 · 1937

Unemployment stayed high

In 1937, eight years after the fall began, unemployment was still far above its 1929 level.

In 1937, 7,700,000 people were out of work. Yet factories and mines were making more than they had in 1929.

In 1938 unemployment rose again. The 1938 average was the worst since 1933.

Unemployment never got back to its 1929 level before the Second World War, so the hardship lasted about a decade.

Unemployment was 3.2 per cent in 1929 and 24.9 per cent in 1933, its worst year. Where was it in 1937, four years after that worst year?

For scaleIn 1929, before the fall, the rate was 3.2 per cent.

Step 8 · 1945

The figures were built later

Take a guess

Why can two accounts of the 1930s give different unemployment figures for the same year?

The Bureau of Labor Statistics built the 1929 to 1939 unemployment figures in 1945.

The Bureau did the work six years after the decade ended, using tax records, census returns and industry surveys. It built its estimates so they could be compared with the figures published at the time by the Census Bureau, which ran the census.

In 1948 the Bureau published an article explaining its work. Table 2 of that article is headed "Selected estimates of unemployment in the United States 1929-39". The table lists different answers to the same question.

Every unemployment figure for the 1930s was worked out later, and the organisations that publish them say so plainly.

For scaleThe first American national income report reached the Senate in January 1934.

Your score
0 points

Your score will appear here.

The key questions

Can you answer each one now? Tap to check.

Why did Hoover's response not stop the fall?

RevealHoover did act, with public works and a government lender, but his action was far too small for the size of the collapse.

Did the people who kept their jobs escape the Depression?

RevealNo. Pay for each hour fell and so did the hours worked, so the wage income of people in work fell much further than their hourly pay.

Why did the hardship last a decade rather than a few years?

RevealUnemployment stayed high for the whole decade. It was still high in 1937, when factories were producing more than in 1929, and it rose again in 1938. It never returned to its 1929 level before the Second World War.

Why do the unemployment figures for the 1930s differ?

RevealThere was no regular count of unemployment at the time. The figures were worked out afterwards from other records, and different choices give different answers for the same year.

The numbers

Can you remember each figure? Tap to check.

Hoover's public works

Reveal$1.5 billion

States the dry conditions touched

Reveal30, of 48

Factory pay and hours, 1929 to 1933

Revealpay -21.4% an hour, weekly hours -13.8%

Wage income for people who kept work

Reveal-42.5%

figures in 1929

Revealnone existed

First report, ordered and delivered

Reveal1932, and January 1934

in 1937, eight years on

Reveal14.3%

When the 1930s figures were built

Reveal1945

You met two terms in this module

,

national income
The total value of everything a country produces in a year. Government figures are usually given as a share of it, because that is what makes a sum comparable between one decade and another.
unemployment
The number of people who want paid work and cannot find it, usually given as a share of all those working or looking for work. People who are not looking are not counted, so the figure understates how many are out of work.

That is what the Depression cost, and how poorly it was measured at the time. A new government response began in March 1933.

Take it further

Where every figure came from

[1] Why there were no figures: Bureau of Economic Analysis, Survey of Current Business, The evolution of US national income accounting. "In 1932, U.S. Senator Robert La Follette, in Senate Resolution 220, directed the BFDC to produce a report on U.S. national income for the period 1929-1931." The work "was driven in part by the lessons learned during World War I, when a lack of data made economic planning difficult, and the ongoing crisis of the Great Depression", and the result "was the first U.S. economics report of its kind". Simon Kuznets managed the study and the report reached the Senate in January 1934.
[2] When the figures were built: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Monthly Labor Review, Stanley Lebergott, Labor force, employment and unemployment 1929-39. "In 1945, the BLS developed and made available preliminary estimates of labor force, employment, and unemployment for the 1929-39 period, comparable with those then published by the Bureau of the Census." The article's Table 2 is headed "Selected estimates of unemployment in the United States 1929-39", and lists rival answers to the same question.
[3] The count that was attacked: US Census Bureau, 1930 Census. The 1930 unemployment figures "were attacked as being too low", and "Congress required a special unemployment census for January 1931; the data it produced confirmed the severity of the situation".
[4] What the figures showed: Congressional Research Service, Labor Market Data: Great Depression vs. Recent Recession, R40655. Unemployment was 14.3% in 1937 and averaged 19.0% in 1938. Between 1929 and 1933 average hourly earnings for manufacturing factory workers declined by 21.4%, while average weekly hours decreased by 13.8%. The report states that the 1930s figures are estimates made afterwards, designed to be comparable with the survey used today.
[5] What happened to wages: FDR Presidential Library and Museum, Great Depression Facts. Workers lucky enough to keep their jobs saw their wage income fall by 42.5% from 1929 to 1933. That is total wage income, a different measure from the hourly earnings figure the Congressional Research Service gives.
[6] Who the 1935 law covered: Social Security Administration, Larry DeWitt, The decision to exclude agricultural and domestic workers from the 1935 Social Security Act, Social Security Bulletin 70(4). "It is true that from the 1930 Census... we can observe that about 65 percent of gainfully employed African Americans worked in the agricultural or domestic sectors of the economy." And: "Although 65 percent of the African American workforce was excluded by this provision, it was also the case that 27 percent of the white workforce was likewise excluded from coverage." And: "Of those individuals excluded under the provision, 74 percent were white, and only 23 percent were African American." DeWitt argues against reading the exclusion as racially intended, and all three figures are printed together for that reason, with no motive attached.
[7] How many people were out of work: US Department of Labor, History, Chapter 5: Americans in Depression and War. "The Bureau of Labor Statistics later estimated that 12,830,000 persons were out of work in 1933." In 1937 there were still 7,700,000 people unemployed, even though "industrial production exceeded the level reached in 1929".
[8] What the president did, and what the weather did: Herbert Hoover Presidential Library and Museum, The Great Depression. The exhibit is organised by year, 1929 to 1933. It records the public works money and that "On January 22, 1932, Hoover established the Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC)". On the drought it says "Dry conditions touched 30 states from the Appalachians to the Rockies".
[9] What happened on the land: Library of Congress, The Dust Bowl, US History Primary Source Timeline. "Between 1930 and 1940, the southwestern Great Plains region of the United States suffered a severe drought." EH.net's encyclopedia dates the same drought from 1933, which is why no start year is stated anywhere in the prose.
[10] The episode chart: US Bureau of Economic Analysis, Gross domestic income: Compensation of employees, paid: Wages and salaries (A4102C1A027NBEA), via FRED. Public domain, citation requested on FRED. Annual, billions of current dollars. Retrieved 30 September 2026. This is the whole American wage bill. It falls by the same share between 1929 and 1933 as the wage income figure in the step, which comes from the FDR Library.

Country data from the World Bank (CC BY 4.0) and the UNDP Human Development Report (CC BY 3.0 IGO)
Games · Learn · Atlas · Read · Feedback · Privacy · Contact