Nixon spoke to the nation on a Sunday evening
At 9 p.m. on Sunday 15 August 1971, President Richard Nixon spoke to Americans on radio and television from the Oval Office. Inflation, the rate at which prices in general rise, had run at about 5 to 6 per cent a year in America in 1969 and 1970. Foreign governments held dollars that they could take to the US Treasury and swap for gold at a fixed price. Nixon used the broadcast to announce a change to those swaps.
Before you start
What you'll be able to answer
- What did the United States change about dollars and gold in August 1971, and why?
- What else did Nixon do in August 1971, and was freezing wages and prices an American idea?
- How did the system of fixed exchange rates end, and what replaced it?
Foreign governments could swap their dollars for American gold at a fixed price. What did Nixon announce about that?
He stopped the swaps. The next two sections show why the swaps could no longer go on.
Where this sits
The Great Inflation — 1971 to 1982 · this module is lit
- 15 Aug 1971The United States stops turning dollars into gold, freezes wages and prices, and puts a tax on imports
- Dec 1971–Mar 1973New fixed rates are agreed in December 1971, with the dollar devalued against gold; they break down, and by March 1973 the main currencies float
- 1972Food and commodity prices start to climb, while consumer prices across the rich world are already rising
- Oct 1973Arab oil producers embargo shipments to the United States and the Netherlands
- 1974Imported crude costs US refiners far more than in 1973; in America inflation and unemployment rise together
- Jan 1976At a meeting in Jamaica, IMF members agree that each country may choose its exchange-rate arrangement; gold is to lose its official price
- 1979Iran's revolution cuts its oil production, and the oil price rises a second time
- Oct 1979The Federal Reserve raises its discount rate, the rate at which it lends to banks, and most of the other countries the series follows raise an official rate within two months
- 1982Net bank lending to the developing countries that did not export oil halves, and a debt crisis begins
- 1983Inflation is below its peak in all eleven countries the series follows
The dollar had a price in gold, and other currencies a price in dollars
Until 1971, each main country's government kept its currency at a fixed price in dollars, called a fixed exchange rate. The dollar had an official price in gold of $35 an ounce. A government holding dollars could ask the US Treasury for gold at that price.
The system of fixed rates and gold swaps had run into trouble often in the years before it ended. Nixon told his audience that for seven years there had been "an average of one international monetary crisis every year".
Nixon also said that speculators, traders who bet on price changes, had spent recent weeks betting that the dollar would lose value. Whenever traders expected a fixed rate to change, they moved money out of the currency they thought would fall.
More dollars were held abroad than America had in reserves
The President's Council of Economic Advisers later gave one reason the dollar was judged overvalued, or priced too high. From 1965 to 1969, American wages and prices rose faster than abroad, and output per worker did not grow enough to make up the gap. American goods became harder to sell.
America sold more abroad than it bought, yet this trade surplus was smaller in 1970 than in the 1960s. In 1971 it became a deficit. Counting military spending, aid and investment abroad, more dollars left America each year than came back.
By 1971 America's gold and other reserve assets were worth about $14.5 billion. The dollars held abroad far exceeded that. Anyone expecting a devaluation, a cut in the dollar's official value, would want gold first.
From January to mid-August 1971 the Treasury paid out more than $3 billion of reserves, about 40 per cent of it in early August.
At Camp David, the advisers split over the gold window
On Friday 13 August 1971 Nixon took his economic advisers to Camp David, the presidential retreat in Maryland. He ordered that nothing leak before an announcement. Paul Volcker began by reporting how much gold America had lost that day. He would later chair the Federal Reserve, America's central bank. The Treasury Secretary, John Connally, proposed one package. It would close the "gold window", the Treasury's promise to swap dollars for gold. It would also tax imports, change taxes, and freeze wages and prices. Arthur Burns, chair of the Federal Reserve, backed most of it but argued hard against closing the window.
Your decision
You are President Nixon at Camp David. What do you do about the gold window?
If dollars cannot be swapped for gold, holders cannot rush to get gold before it runs out.
Where it was triedThis is Connally's plan. He argued that America no longer had the reserves to pay out for all the dollars held abroad. He said that waiting would let other countries decide what happened to the dollar.
What it costsOther governments get no say in the decision. Burns warned they would see it as an act against their interests. He also warned that the President would be blamed for devaluing the dollar. Ending gold swaps would be seen as cutting the dollar's value.
If you hold the import tax back, you can offer to drop it in the talks on new exchange rates.
Where it was triedThis is Volcker's preference. He was the official who would negotiate abroad.
What it costsNixon expected that if he held the tax back, Congress would pass its own limits on imports, and he thought those would be worse.
Strong action at home might, on its own, stop people selling dollars.
Where it was triedThis is Burns's case. He said the central banks he heard from every day would welcome the steps at home. He said they would then not ask for gold.
What it costsIf people kept selling dollars, America would keep losing gold and the window would close anyway. It would close later, with less gold left.
Nixon took Connally's plan. On the Sunday evening he announced that he had directed Connally "to suspend temporarily the convertibility of the dollar into gold", meaning the right to swap dollars for gold. He announced the import tax and the freeze at the same time. Burns had called closing the window unilateral action, taken by America alone against other countries' interests. The main European governments kept their currency markets shut for the following week. They tried to agree a joint response to America's move and failed.
What followedThe import tax did not last. In December the United States dropped it as part of the deal that set new exchange rates.
The same speech froze wages and prices and taxed imports
In the same speech, Nixon announced cuts to taxes and federal spending. He also ordered "a freeze on all prices and wages throughout the United States for a period of 90 days".
Nixon also put a temporary tax of 10 per cent on goods imported into the United States. He said the tax would end once exchange rates he called unfair to America had been put right.
The freeze ran until 13 November 1971 and covered rents and salaries as well as prices and wages. The order banned prices, rents, wages and salaries above their levels before the freeze. Anyone who broke it on purpose could be fined. Congress had given the President the power to do this a year earlier, in the Economic Stabilization Act of 1970.
Check yourself
Three of the four items below were in Nixon's announcement of August 1971. Which one was not?
Wage and price controls ran in four phases, and Britain used them too
The freeze was the first of four phases of controls. Phase II, from November 1971 to January 1973, replaced the freeze with rules run by a Pay Board and a Price Commission. In 1973 the controls became mostly voluntary, and prices were frozen again that summer. The last phase ended on 30 April 1974.
America was not the only country to freeze pay and prices. In July 1966 the British government called for a six-month standstill, meaning no rises, on wages and salaries, and a similar standstill on prices.
In November 1972 Britain went further. It brought in a legal standstill on increases in pay, prices, rents and dividends, the payments companies make to shareholders. Whether wage and price controls changed how far prices rose is a question for later in this series.
In December 1971 the main countries agreed a new set of fixed exchange rates. How long did they hold?
They began to break in June 1972, when Britain let the pound float, meaning its value was left to the market. They gave way completely in February and March 1973.
The fixed rates agreed in December 1971 gave way by March 1973
In December 1971 the Group of Ten countries met at the Smithsonian Institution in Washington. They agreed a new set of fixed exchange rates.
The official price of gold would rise to $38 an ounce, so a dollar would be worth less gold. The Japanese yen was made worth 16.88 per cent more against the dollar.
Traders doubted the new rates would last. In June 1972 Britain let the pound float, which meant the market set its value.
On 12 February 1973 America announced a second devaluation of the dollar, after the gold price rise of December 1971. The yen was allowed to float at the same time.
On 1 March traders sold more than $3.6 billion to European central banks, and Europe's currency markets closed. When the markets reopened on 19 March, the main currencies floated, with the market setting their prices.
Check yourself
Predict: in early 1971 a dollar bought about 358 Japanese yen. After the gold window closed, the December deal made the yen worth more against the dollar. About how many yen did a dollar buy in January 1972?
313 yen
About 313 yen. From August 1971 to January 1972, the dollar lost about an eighth of its value against the yen. A dollar bought fewer yen, so Japanese goods cost more in America and American goods cost less in Japan.
Floating rates moved far more than the fixed ones had
In the first half of 1971 the yen barely moved against the dollar, because the rate was fixed. The chart runs to 1980, past the breaks of 1971 and 1973.
A floating rate moves whenever buyers and sellers change their view of a currency. On the chart, the line drops at each break, as a dollar buys fewer yen. After that it moves up and down.
Japanese exporters and American importers now had to watch the exchange rate every day, because it could change every day.
Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Japanese Yen to U.S. Dollar Spot Exchange Rate (EXJPUS), via FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.
Check yourself
Look at the chart. In which year did a dollar buy the fewest yen?
Check yourself
Predict: what happened to American inflation in the decade after 1971?
A decade of high inflation followed
The end of fixed rates came at the start of a long period of high inflation, which this series calls the Great Inflation. American inflation reached double figures in 1974, and again in each year from 1979 to 1981.
The price of oil jumped twice. The first came in 1973 and 1974, when Arab oil producers held back oil for political reasons. This was the Arab oil embargo. The second came after the revolution in Iran in 1979.
In August 1979 Paul Volcker became chair of the Federal Reserve. Interest rates rose sharply over the following months. By 1983 American inflation had fallen a long way.
Economists still argue about what caused the high inflation. Some mainly blame bad luck: the oil shocks. Others blame bad policy: central banks let too much money be created and lent. They also argue about whether the end of fixed rates helped cause it.
Check yourself
The key questions
What did the United States change about dollars and gold in August 1971, and why?
Far more dollars were held overseas than America had in gold and other reserve assets. The President's advisers gave one reason: American wages and prices had risen faster than abroad. Holders who expected a devaluation asked for gold. Nixon closed the gold window to stop the Treasury paying out its reserves.
What else did Nixon do in August 1971, and was freezing wages and prices an American idea?
It froze wages, prices, rents and salaries by law and taxed imports. America was not the only country to freeze pay and prices: Britain called a standstill in 1966 and brought in a legal one in 1972.
How did the system of fixed exchange rates end, and what replaced it?
New fixed rates agreed in December 1971 began to break in 1972 and gave way in February and March 1973. From March the market set the main currencies' rates. A decade of high inflation followed, and economists still argue about what caused it.
The numbers
Check yourself
Why did Nixon stop swapping dollars for gold?
Check yourself
Was freezing wages and prices an American idea?
Check yourself
By late March 1973, what had happened to the main currencies?