- Monopoly
- A monopoly is a firm that sells all or nearly all of the goods and services in a given market, so it faces the market demand curve.
- Price taker
- A price taker is a firm that must accept the prevailing equilibrium price in its market, because the pressure of competing firms forces it to.
OutputMR cuts MC at Qm: the output that makes profit as large as it can be.
At output Qm, where MC = MR, go up past average cost C1 to the demand curve for the price Pm; the gap is profit per unit.
- The monopoly first chooses the output where marginal revenue equals marginal cost, Qm. Below it each unit adds to profit, and beyond it each unit takes profit away.
- It then charges what the market will pay for Qm, read straight up at the demand curve: Pm. No monopolist can make buyers take more than they want at that price.
- Total revenue is Pm × Qm and total cost is C1 × Qm, so supernormal profit is the rectangle between Pm and C1, out to Qm.
- In the long run the monopoly keeps this profit. Barriers to entry stop the new firms that would erode it in a competitive market.
Check yourself
This monopoly produces where MR = MC. Which area is its supernormal profit?
Yes. X runs from average cost up to the price, across every unit sold: revenue minus total cost.
Y is average cost times output: the firm's total cost, including normal profit. It is not profit above that.
Z lies beyond the monopoly's output, on units it never makes. It is the deadweight loss, not anyone's profit.
Compare the monopoly with a competitive industry that has the same costs. What do you think the monopoly does?
Price and quantity are tied by the demand curve, so the monopoly cannot charge more without selling less. It raises its price by holding output below what competition would bring.
MonopolyThe monopoly produces Qm, where MR = MC, and charges Pm.
Compared with a competitive industry at Pc and Qc, the monopoly moves left along demand to a lower output Qm and a higher price Pm.
- A competitive industry would produce where price equals marginal cost, at Qc. At the monopoly's output Qm, price is above marginal cost: buyers value one more unit at more than it would cost to make, and it goes unmade.
- That makes the monopoly allocatively inefficient. The triangle between the demand curve and MC, from Qm to Qc, is the deadweight loss.
- Here Qm also lies to the left of the lowest point of ATC, so the monopoly does not produce at the lowest possible average cost. With no entry to push it there, it stays productively inefficient in the long run too.
Check yourself
At a monopoly's profit-maximising output, price is £40 and marginal cost is £25. What does this show?
Can't a monopoly just charge whatever price it likes?
It can choose any price, but the demand for its product still limits it. No monopolist, even one thoroughly protected by barriers to entry, can make consumers buy. A higher price means a lower quantity sold, so the monopolist has to find the price and quantity pair that makes profit largest. That is why it produces where MR = MC and reads its price off the demand curve, rather than charging the highest price anyone would pay.
Draw MR below AR, starting at the same point on the price axis and twice as steep. Mark Qm where MC cuts MR, then go up to AR for Pm and down to ATC for average cost. Shade the profit between them. For inefficiency, mark where AR meets MC and shade the deadweight-loss triangle back to Qm.
Check yourself
Why can a monopoly keep making supernormal profit in the long run, when a perfectly competitive firm cannot?
Exam question
Using a diagram, explain why a monopoly is allocatively and productively inefficient. [4]
The monopoly produces Qm, where MR = MC, and charges Pm from the demand curve. At Qm price is above marginal cost, so buyers value extra units at more than they cost to make: it is allocatively inefficient, with a deadweight loss between D and MC from Qm to where D meets MC. Qm is also below the output at the lowest point of ATC, so it does not produce at minimum average cost and is productively inefficient.
One mark for Qm at MR = MC with Pm from AR; one for P > MC; one for the deadweight-loss triangle; one for Qm left of the ATC minimum. A diagram with MR drawn level with AR loses the first mark.
A monopoly faces the market demand curve. It produces where marginal revenue equals marginal cost and charges the price buyers will pay for that output, read off the demand curve. When that price is above average cost it earns supernormal profit, which barriers to entry protect in the long run. Price is above marginal cost, so it is allocatively inefficient, and it does not produce at the lowest average cost.