- Long-run Phillips curve
- The long-run Phillips curve is a vertical line at the natural rate of unemployment, showing no long-run trade-off between inflation and unemployment.
- Short-run Phillips curve
- The short-run Phillips curve slopes down, showing a trade-off between unemployment and inflation that holds for periods of several years.
Where unemployment settles, and how people form expectations
Can you name two ideas about the long-run rate of unemployment and the two theories of expectations?
The long-run curve rests on two ideas: a rate of unemployment the economy returns to, and expectations that catch up with inflation.
The natural rate of unemployment is the rate of unemployment that would remain if the economy were neither booming nor in recession.
Can you think of an example?
Even in a strong economy some people are between jobs and some lack the skills employers want, so unemployment never reaches zero.
The NAIRU is the rate of unemployment at which inflation neither speeds up nor slows down, so holding unemployment below it makes inflation keep rising.
Can you think of an example?
If the NAIRU is about four per cent, holding unemployment at three per cent means inflation rising year after year, not settling at a higher rate.
Adaptive expectations are formed by looking at past experience and gradually adapting beliefs as circumstances change.
Can you think of an example?
After two years of five per cent inflation, workers start to ask for pay rises of five per cent, because that is what prices have been doing.
Rational expectations are the most accurate forecasts people can make about the future using all the information available to them.
Can you think of an example?
Told the government will boost demand, firms and workers expect higher prices straight away and raise them now, so output hardly changes.
StartUnemployment is at the natural rate U*, with inflation π0 that people expect: point A, on SRPC0 and on the vertical LRPC.
Higher demand moves the economy along SRPC0 from A to B: unemployment falls from U* to U1 and inflation rises from π0 to π1.
- At first workers expect inflation of π0, so they accept pay rises that turn out to be worth less than they thought, and firms hire more.
- Once workers see inflation at π1, they build it into their pay claims. Real wages rise back, firms hire fewer, and unemployment drifts back to U*.
- The short-run curve has shifted up to SRPC1: the economy is at C, with the same unemployment as at A and higher inflation.
Check yourself
Inflation has been higher than people expected for two years, and workers now expect it to continue. Which way does the short-run Phillips curve move?
Two long-run pointsA and C both sit on LRPC at U*: the economy can settle at the natural rate with inflation of π0 or π1.
With expectations adjusted, the short-run curve has shifted up and unemployment is back at U*, with inflation up from π0 to π1.
- Joining the long-run points A and C gives a vertical line at U*: the long-run Phillips curve. Any rate of inflation is consistent with the natural rate.
- To hold unemployment at U1 again, demand must rise faster still, moving along SRPC1 to D with inflation at π2. So the natural rate behaves as a NAIRU: below it, inflation accelerates.
- Milton Friedman summed it up in 1967: there is always a temporary trade-off between inflation and unemployment; there is no permanent trade-off. Lower unemployment in the long run needs supply-side policy that lowers the natural rate itself.
If the long-run curve is vertical, is the Phillips curve useless?
No. It still describes the short run, which can last several years, and it explains stagflation: when expectations or supply shocks shift the short-run curve, unemployment and inflation rise together, as in the 1970s. Its limits are that the short-run curve keeps moving, so it is no menu of choices, and nobody can observe the natural rate directly. Rational expectations would make even the short-run trade-off vanish, but people and firms are rarely that well informed.
Draw LRPC as a vertical line at the natural rate, with two short-run curves, and number the moves: along the first short-run curve, then the curve shifts up. Say "expected inflation rises" to explain the shift. To evaluate, argue that supply-side policy to cut the natural rate, not higher demand, lowers unemployment for good.
Check yourself
The chart shows a short-run Phillips curve and a vertical line at one rate of unemployment. Which point could be a long-run equilibrium?
A is on the vertical line: unemployment is at the natural rate, with inflation at the rate people expect, so nothing pushes the economy away.
B has unemployment below the natural rate. Inflation is higher than expected, so expectations will rise and the economy will not stay here.
C has unemployment above the natural rate, with inflation below what people expect. Pay claims will ease and unemployment will drift back.
Check yourself
A government keeps unemployment below the NAIRU year after year. According to the long-run Phillips curve, what happens to inflation?
Exam question
Using a Phillips curve diagram, explain why there may be no long-run trade-off between unemployment and inflation. [6]
Start at A: unemployment at the natural rate, U*, inflation as expected. Higher demand moves the economy along SRPC0: unemployment falls to U1 and inflation rises to π1. Workers then expect π1 and build it into pay claims, so real wages recover, firms hire fewer and the short-run curve shifts up to SRPC1. Unemployment returns to U* at C with higher inflation. Joining A and C gives a vertical long-run Phillips curve: in the long run, lower unemployment cannot be bought with higher inflation.
Marks for: the move along the short-run curve; expectations adjusting; the short-run curve shifting up; unemployment returning to the natural rate; the vertical long-run curve; a correctly labelled diagram. An answer with no expectations mechanism caps at three.
In the short run, higher demand trades lower unemployment for higher inflation, a move along the short-run Phillips curve. Once people expect the higher inflation, the short-run curve shifts up and unemployment returns to its natural rate. So the long-run Phillips curve is vertical at the natural rate: any inflation rate is consistent with it. Holding unemployment below this rate, the NAIRU, makes inflation accelerate. Only supply-side change lowers unemployment for good.