- Keynesian cross
- The Keynesian cross is a diagram that finds the equilibrium level of real GDP where aggregate expenditure in the economy equals the amount of output produced.
- Aggregate expenditure schedule
- The aggregate expenditure schedule shows the total spending in the economy, made up of consumption, investment, government spending and net exports, at each level of real GDP.
Three ideas that decide where output settles
Can you name the three ideas that decide where output settles in the Keynesian cross?
At A-level the multiplier says how far output moves after a change in spending. These three say where it stops, and why it can stop in the wrong place.
An unplanned change in inventories is unsold goods piling up, or shelves emptying, because planned spending differs from output, which tells firms to change production.
Can you think of an example?
A car maker plans for sales that do not come, and unsold cars fill its yards. It cuts shifts the next month, so its output falls towards what buyers plan to spend.
A recessionary gap is the amount by which equilibrium real GDP falls short of potential GDP, so firms do not wish to hire the full-employment number of workers.
Can you think of an example?
Equilibrium output is £60 billion below potential GDP and the multiplier is three. A rise in government spending of £20 billion, not £60 billion, is enough to close the gap.
The paradox of thrift is the result that when every household tries to save more, national income falls and total saving need not rise at all.
Can you think of an example?
In a slump, worried families cut spending to build up savings. Shops sell less, their staff lose hours and earn less, and those staff save less, so total saving rises far less than families planned, and in a closed economy with fixed investment not at all.
EquilibriumPlanned spending equals output at E0, where AE0 crosses the forty-five-degree line, so real GDP is Y0.
A rise in investment shifts the aggregate expenditure line up from AE0 to AE1, and equilibrium real GDP rises from Y0 to Y1, by more than the shift.
- Equilibrium is where the AE line crosses the line at forty-five degrees, the only point where planned spending equals output.
- At the old output Y0, planned spending now exceeds output. Shelves empty, firms raise production, and each rise in output becomes income, part of which is spent again.
- Output stops rising at Y1. The rise in output is bigger than the vertical shift, by the multiplier, 1 ÷ (1 − the slope of AE): the A-level multiplier, drawn.
- The slope of AE is the share of each extra pound of income spent on domestic output: the MPC reduced by taxes and imports. More saving, tax or imports flatten the line and shrink the multiplier.
Check yourself
The AE line has a slope of 0.75. Investment rises by £10 billion. By how much does equilibrium real GDP rise?
In a simple economy with no government and no trade, where investment does not depend on income, every household decides to save more. What do you think happens to total saving?
With no government or trade and investment fixed, saving more means spending less, so output and incomes fall until saving is back where it started. If investment falls with income, saving ends lower.
BeforeSaving equals investment at E0, so real GDP is Y0.
Households save more at every income, so the saving line shifts up from S0 to S1 and real GDP falls from Y0 to Y1, with saving no higher.
- Take the simplest economy, with no government and no trade. Output equals planned spending exactly when planned saving equals planned investment: what leaks out of the flow of spending equals what is put in.
- When households try to save more of every income, they spend less. The AE line shifts down and output falls, by the multiplier.
- Investment does not depend on income here, so the new equilibrium still has saving equal to the same investment. Income falls until people can afford to save only what they saved before.
- If investment falls as income falls, total saving ends lower. The result weakens if a lower interest rate lifts investment, or over the long run, when saving pays for new capital.
Check yourself
Business confidence collapses and firms cut planned investment at every level of income. Which way does the aggregate expenditure line move?
Can a big enough rise in spending push real GDP as high as you like?
No. Push the AE line up far enough and it crosses the forty-five-degree line beyond potential GDP, an inflationary gap. Read that gap as spending in excess of what is needed to reach potential GDP, not as a forecast of output. The economy faces supply-side limits from its workers, capital and technology, so the extra spending raises the price level instead. The price level appears only implicitly, through the inflationary gap, so here the analysis hands over to AD/AS.
Draw the forty-five-degree line from the origin and an AE line flatter than it, crossing it once. Label the axes aggregate expenditure and real GDP, never price and quantity. Show a change in spending as a parallel shift of AE, then mark both equilibria on the horizontal axis so the rise in output is visibly bigger than the vertical shift.
Check yourself
Which point shows an output at which unsold goods are piling up in firms' warehouses?
A is where AE crosses the forty-five-degree line. Planned spending equals output, so nothing piles up and nothing runs short: this is equilibrium.
Right. At B the AE line lies below the forty-five-degree line, so output exceeds planned spending. Unsold goods pile up and firms cut production towards A.
At C the AE line lies above the forty-five-degree line, so planned spending exceeds output. Shelves empty and firms raise production towards A.
Exam question
A car maker's unsold cars are filling its car parks. What does that tell you about the economy, and what happens next? [4]
If it is happening across the economy, output is above planned spending: in the Keynesian cross the economy sits to the right of equilibrium, where AE lies below the forty-five-degree line, and the unsold cars are an unplanned rise in inventories. Firms cut production; as output and incomes fall, spending falls by less, so the gap closes at the equilibrium. Two assumptions could break it: the model fixes prices, and firms might cut prices instead of output; and one firm's unsold stock may be sales lost to a rival, not weak demand overall.
A strong answer states the model and where the economy is on it, applies the adjustment through inventories and output, and then names an assumption that could break it, such as fixed prices or reading one firm as the whole economy.
Exam question
Real GDP is £100 billion below potential. Should the government spend an extra £100 billion? [4]
Not by the Keynesian cross. The gap is measured on the horizontal axis, but extra spending shifts the AE line vertically, and output rises by the multiplier. With a multiplier of two, about £50 billion closes the recessionary gap, and £100 billion would push output past potential into an inflationary gap. The answer rests on knowing the multiplier, which is uncertain: it is smaller if borrowing to pay for the spending pushes up interest rates and cuts investment, or if households save much of a temporary boost.
The interviewer wants the multiplier applied to a gap, the arithmetic in the right direction (divide the gap by the multiplier), and then doubt about the multiplier's size, which is where the Keynesian cross is weakest.
The Keynesian cross puts aggregate expenditure on the vertical axis and real GDP on the horizontal. Equilibrium is where the AE line crosses the forty-five-degree line, where planned spending equals output; away from it, unplanned changes in inventories push firms back towards it. A shift in AE moves output by the multiplier, and equilibrium can sit below potential GDP, a recessionary gap, or above it, an inflationary gap. When every household tries to save more, income falls and total saving need not rise.