- Keynesian aggregate supply curve
- The Keynesian aggregate supply curve is flat far below potential GDP, because wages and prices are sticky, and turns vertical at potential GDP.
- Classical long-run aggregate supply
- Classical long-run aggregate supply is a vertical line at potential GDP, so it determines real output wherever aggregate demand is drawn.
Zones of the aggregate supply curve
Can you name the three zones of the aggregate supply curve?
Where AD crosses AS decides whether extra spending buys output or only higher prices.
The Keynesian zone is the flat part of the curve far below potential GDP, where shifts in AD change output but barely move the price level.
Can you think of an example?
In a deep recession with many factories half-empty, a rise in government spending raises output and jobs with almost no rise in prices.
The intermediate zone is the curved middle section, where a rise in AD raises both output and the price level.
Can you think of an example?
With some spare capacity left, a rise in consumer spending lifts real GDP and cuts unemployment, but prices start to rise as well.
The neoclassical zone is the near-vertical part close to potential GDP, where shifts in AD mostly change the price level.
Can you think of an example?
At full employment, firms cannot find extra workers, so a rise in spending mainly bids up wages and prices, and output barely changes.
Deep recessionFar below full employment the Keynesian AS curve is flat. AD0 meets it at price level P1 and real GDP Y1.
In a deep recession AD shifts right along the flat AS curve, so real GDP rises from Y1 to Y2 with the price level unchanged at P1.
- Keynes argued that recessions come from too little demand, not a loss of capacity: the workers, factories and technology are all still there.
- Because wages and prices are sticky, firms respond to extra spending by producing more, not by raising prices, so AD decides output.
- Near full employment the curve turns vertical, and extra demand only raises prices. So in this view demand policy works best in a deep recession.
Check yourself
At which point would a rise in aggregate demand raise real GDP with almost no rise in the price level?
A is on the flat section far below full capacity. Idle resources let firms produce more without raising prices, so output rises and prices barely move.
B is on the curved middle section. Extra demand raises output, but some firms are near their limits, so the price level rises as well.
C is on the vertical section at full capacity. Firms cannot produce more, so extra demand shows up almost entirely as a higher price level.
The economy is at full employment when aggregate demand rises for good. In the classical view, what happens to real GDP in the long run?
Output can rise above potential for a while, but workers are scarce, so wages are bid up and SRAS shifts left. Output returns to potential and all that remains is a higher price level.
At potentialAD0 meets SRAS0 on the vertical LRAS line: real GDP is at full employment, Yf, and the price level is P1.
AD shifts right, but in the long run real GDP returns to full employment Yf and the price level rises from P1 to P3.
- Classical economists hold that wages and prices are sticky only in the short run and flexible over time.
- Output above Yf means a shortage of workers, so employers bid up wages. Dearer labour shifts SRAS left until real GDP is back at Yf.
- So LRAS is vertical at potential GDP: in the long run a rise in demand raises the price level, not output. Only a rise in capacity moves real GDP.
Check yourself
According to the classical view, which of these raises real GDP in the long run?
If LRAS is vertical, can government spending never raise output?
It can in the short run, even in the classical view: output rises past potential until wages catch up. The dispute is over how long the short run lasts. Keynesians argue wages fall so slowly after a recession that waiting for the economy to heal itself costs years of lost output; Keynes put it as "In the long run we are all dead." Classical economists reply that even ten years of adjustment leaves potential GDP deciding output in the end.
Draw the Keynesian curve with a flat section, a curved section and a vertical section at full employment, Yf. Draw the classical case as SRAS with a vertical LRAS at Yf. Then say what each implies: with a large negative output gap, higher AD raises output; at full employment it only raises prices.
Check yourself
Unemployment is very high and factories are running well below capacity. Which statement fits the Keynesian view?
Exam question
Explain why Keynesian and classical economists disagree about the effect of an increase in aggregate demand on real output. [4]
Keynesians draw AS flat far below full employment, because wages and prices are sticky, so a rise in AD raises output with little inflation in a recession. Classical economists hold that wages and prices are flexible in the long run, so LRAS is vertical at potential GDP: a rise in AD raises output only briefly, then wages rise, SRAS shifts left and only the price level is higher.
Two marks for each view: the shape of the curve and the reason for it (sticky wages; flexible wages in the long run), and what that means for output. Stating the shapes with no reason earns two.
The Keynesian AS curve is flat far below full employment, because wages and prices are sticky, curves upwards as capacity is approached and turns vertical at full employment. So in a recession AD decides output. The classical view is that wages and prices are flexible in the long run, so LRAS is vertical at potential GDP and a rise in AD ends as a higher price level. Only a rise in capacity raises long-run output.