- Laissez-faire
- Laissez-faire is the view that government should leave markets largely alone, doing little beyond protecting property and enforcing contracts.
- Mercantilism
- Mercantilism is the view that a nation grows rich by exporting more than it imports and building up gold and silver, with the state steering trade.
Six schools of thought followed the mercantilists and physiocrats
Can you name the six schools of economic thought that followed the mercantilists and physiocrats, in the order they arose?
Each card gives the school's main idea and a person linked to it.
Classical economists, from Adam Smith to the mid-nineteenth century, held that free markets allocate resources well and that supply creates its own demand.
Can you think of an example?
Smith's The Wealth of Nations (1776) showed how dividing work into tasks raises output. David Ricardo argued in 1817 that countries gain by specialising and trading.
Karl Marx argued that capitalism's profits come from the unpaid labour of workers, and that its crises and class conflict would bring it to an end.
Can you think of an example?
In Das Kapital, whose first volume appeared in the second half of the nineteenth century, Marx argued that workers produce more than the wage they are paid.
Marginalists, from the late nineteenth century, explained prices by choices at the margin: the extra satisfaction from one more unit, weighed against its price.
Can you think of an example?
In 1890 Alfred Marshall joined demand and supply, likening them to the two blades of a pair of scissors. This approach still underlies microeconomics.
Keynesians hold that total demand can fall short of what an economy can produce, leaving lasting unemployment, so government should manage demand.
Can you think of an example?
John Maynard Keynes wrote The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money in the Great Depression of the 1930s, when output had fallen but capacity had not.
Monetarists and new classical economists hold that an economy corrects itself over time, and that managing demand cannot hold unemployment below its natural rate for long.
Can you think of an example?
Milton Friedman argued in 1967 that inflation and unemployment trade off only temporarily, never permanently.
Behavioural economists bring psychology into economics, studying how people's choices depart from the rational model in ways that can be predicted.
Can you think of an example?
Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky reported in 1979 that a loss pains people more than an equal gain pleases them.
Check yourself
An economist says a slump will not end on its own because spending has collapsed, and calls on the government to spend more on roads and schools. Which school does this view belong to?
Each school answered the problems of its own time
Mercantilists served nation states competing for trade. In mid-eighteenth-century France the physiocrats, led by François Quesnay, argued that land alone yields a surplus and called for free trade. They took up the slogan laissez-faire, popularised by Vincent de Gournay, a French trade official close to them. Adam Smith attacked mercantilism in The Wealth of Nations, arguing that people pursuing their own interest are led, as if by an invisible hand, to serve society.
Marx wrote amid the factories of the industrial revolution. Keynes wrote as mass unemployment persisted in the 1930s. Monetarist and new classical ideas gained ground in the 1970s, when inflation and unemployment rose together. Behavioural economics grew as researchers tested how people really choose, and concern for the environment has since brought ideas such as the circular economy.
Check yourself
Which school gained ground when inflation and unemployment rose together in the 1970s?
Didn't each new school prove the one before it wrong?
No. Later schools added to earlier ones more than they replaced them. Marginal analysis still underlies the theory of demand and supply. Keynesian analysis is more useful for the short run, and the neoclassical view, which follows the classical economists, for the long run. Behavioural economics adds psychology to the rational model rather than throwing it away.
Tie each school to its century, a named economist and the one idea it is known for: "Keynes, the Great Depression: demand can stay too low, so government should manage it." When comparing two schools, name the point they disagree on, such as whether a slump cures itself.
Check yourself
Which list puts these schools in the order in which they arose?
Exam question
Explain one difference between the classical and the Keynesian view of how an economy recovers from a slump. [4]
Classical economists held that supply creates its own demand, so every sale is income to someone and spending returns to match output: a slump cures itself as wages and prices adjust, and government need not act. Keynes argued that demand can stay below what the economy can produce, as in the 1930s, leaving lasting unemployment, so government should raise spending to restore demand.
One mark for each view stated and one for the mechanism behind each: Say's law and adjusting prices for the classical view, too little demand and government spending for the Keynesian. Naming the Great Depression as context helps.
Mercantilists sought wealth from trade surpluses. The physiocrats and Adam Smith made the case for laissez-faire, and classical economists held that supply creates its own demand. Marx argued capitalism exploits workers; marginalists explained prices at the margin. Keynes argued demand can stay too low; monetarists and new classical economists that economies correct themselves. Behavioural economists bring in psychology.