Learn › Economic theory › The economic problem

The economic problem

Sustainability and ethical choices in economics

Compare the evidence that growth runs down the environment with the evidence that it need not

Specification: AQA 4.2.3.1 Edexcel 2.5.4

Key terms
Sustainable development
Sustainable development is meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.
Economic growth
Economic growth is a rise in real GDP, the output of goods and services an economy produces, adjusted for inflation.

More environmental protection can cost output, and waste costs both

A production possibility frontier can show the trade-off between economic output and environmental protection. At P a country chooses high output and little protection; at T, high protection and little output. Along the frontier, more protection has an opportunity cost in lost output.

A point such as M, inside the frontier, is productively inefficient. From M a country could have more output with the same protection, at Q, or more protection with the same output, at S. Market-based tools such as pollution taxes and tradable permits can deliver the same protection at lower cost than rigid rules.

Output against environmental protectionVertical axis: Economic output. Horizontal axis: Environmental protection. PPF: a downward-sloping curve.PPFPTMQS
1 of 2

The frontierAt P a country has high output and little protection; at T, high protection and little output.

Moving along the frontier trades output for protection; moving from M to Q or S costs nothing.

Check yourself

A country is at point A. Which point gives it more environmental protection with no loss of output?

A frontier and four pointsVertical axis: Economic output. Horizontal axis: Environmental protection. F: a downward-sloping curve.PPFABCD

The Dasgupta Review finds growth has been bought by running down nature

The Dasgupta Review, an independent review for HM Treasury, estimated that between 1992 and 2014 produced capital per person doubled worldwide and human capital per person rose by about 13 per cent, while natural capital per person fell by nearly 40 per cent. Nature's worth is not reflected in market prices, because much of it is open to all at no charge, so economies invest too little in it. The review also challenges most models of growth, whose focus has been to show that technological progress can in principle overcome the limits of a finite natural world.

The UK government argues that cutting emissions and growing can go together

The government's Net Zero Strategy of 2021 stated that between 1990 and 2019 the UK cut its greenhouse gas emissions by 44 per cent while its economy grew by 78 per cent, faster cuts than any other G7 country.

Those figures count emissions produced within the UK. Defra's carbon footprint, which counts emissions from what UK residents consume wherever in the world they arise, tells a more mixed story: between 1996 and 2023 emissions from goods and services produced and consumed in the UK fell by 49 per cent, while emissions from imports rose by 43 per cent and now make up more than half the footprint.

Check yourself

UK emissions produced within its borders fell by 44 per cent between 1990 and 2019 while its economy grew by 78 per cent. Why is this weaker evidence that growth is sustainable than it first looks?

Where to stand on the frontier is a value judgement, not a finding

Economists have little to say about which point on the frontier a country should choose. Low-income countries put more weight on output, which pays for food, shelter, health care and education; higher-income countries, where more people have the basics, may put more weight on protection. Low-income countries also point out that high-income countries have been the main contributors to global warming, so have little standing to ask others to put the environment before growth. Sustainable development adds people not yet born to those whose needs count.

Exam tip

Put the trade-off first, then the evidence each way with its source: nature's decline in the Dasgupta Review, the UK's falling emissions with its growing economy, and the imported emissions that qualify it. Finish by saying what the answer depends on, such as how emissions are counted, and note that the choice of point on the frontier is normative.

Check yourself

Which of these statements is normative?

Exam question

Assess whether economic growth is compatible with sustainable development. [8]

What to take away

Sustainable development meets present needs without compromising future generations. On a frontier, more protection costs output, but an inefficient country can gain both. The Dasgupta Review found natural capital per person fell by nearly 40 per cent while produced capital doubled. The UK cut the emissions it produces while growing, but emissions from its imports rose. Which point on the frontier to choose is a value judgement, and low- and high-income countries weigh it differently.