- Subsidy
- A subsidy is a payment from the government to a firm, made directly or through lower taxes, when the firm carries out certain actions.
- Indirect tax
- An indirect tax is a tax on spending on goods and services, collected from producers, such as VAT or excise duty.
BeforeBefore the subsidy, demand D meets supply S1 at price P1 and quantity Q1.
A subsidy per unit shifts supply down by the subsidy, so the price consumers pay falls from P1 to P2 and quantity rises from Q1 to Q2.
- Government subsidies reduce the cost of production. Firms will supply each quantity for the old price minus the subsidy, so supply shifts down by the subsidy per unit, which is the same as a shift to the right.
- Consumers pay P2, and producers receive P3, which is P2 plus the subsidy and higher than P1. The cost to the government is the subsidy per unit times Q2: the rectangle between P3 and P2, from zero to Q2.
- Consumers gain most from a cost cut when demand is inelastic, because the shift in supply then brings a much lower price. When demand is elastic, the price falls only slightly and quantity rises instead.
Check yourself
The government pays producers of electric bikes a subsidy on each bike they make. Which way does the supply curve move?
The marketLeft alone, the market settles at Q1, where MPB meets MPC, at price P1. It misses the benefit to other people.
A voucher worth the external benefit moves the market right from Q1 to Q2: suppliers receive P3 per jab, while people vaccinated pay P2, below P1.
- Left alone, the market for flu jabs settles at Q1, where marginal private benefit meets marginal private cost, and misses the protection each jab gives other people.
- A voucher equal to the external benefit per jab, the gap between marginal social benefit and marginal private benefit, carries output to the socially optimal Q2. Suppliers are paid P3, and the voucher covers the gap between P3 and the P2 the person vaccinated pays.
- Paid through the buyer, the voucher raises demand rather than lowering supply; a subsidy of the same size paid to producers would reach the same Q2.
Check yourself
People who get a flu jab are given a voucher worth the external benefit of each jab. Compared with the free market, what happens?
Doesn't the whole subsidy reach consumers as a lower price?
Not usually. Unless demand is perfectly inelastic or supply perfectly elastic, the price consumers pay falls by less than the subsidy, and producers keep the rest as a higher price received. With a £1 subsidy per unit, the price in the shops might fall by 60p while producers receive 40p more than before. How the £1 splits depends on the elasticities, just as it does for a tax.
Draw the new supply curve below the old one by the subsidy per unit. Mark P1, the consumer price P2 and the producer price P3, then shade the cost to the government as the rectangle between P3 and P2 up to Q2. Say who the subsidy is meant to help and whether they actually gain.
Check yourself
The government pays firms a £3 subsidy on each unit. The price consumers pay falls from £10 to £8. What price do producers now receive for each unit?
£11
Producers receive the consumer price plus the subsidy: £8 + £3 = £11, which is £1 more than before. Consumers gain £2 of each £3 and producers £1.
Check yourself
A £2 subsidy per unit raises weekly sales from 1,000 units to 1,500. What does the subsidy cost the government each week?
Exam question
Using a diagram, explain the effect of a subsidy per passenger journey to bus operators on fares and on the number of journeys. [4]
The subsidy lowers the operators' cost of each journey, so supply shifts down by the subsidy per journey. The fare passengers pay falls from P1 to P2 and the number of journeys rises from Q1 to Q2. Operators receive P3, the fare plus the subsidy, which is above P1, so the fare falls by less than the subsidy unless demand is perfectly inelastic or supply perfectly elastic.
One mark each for: lower costs shifting supply down; the fare falling; journeys rising; the producer price P3 above P1, so the gain is shared. Shifting demand instead of supply earns none of the diagram marks.
A subsidy is a government payment to firms for carrying out certain actions. It reduces the cost of production, so supply shifts down by the subsidy per unit: the price consumers pay falls, the quantity rises, and producers receive the consumer price plus the subsidy. It costs the government the subsidy times the new quantity. Aimed at a good with an external benefit, a subsidy can carry output to the social optimum.