- Returns to scale
- Returns to scale describe how much a firm's output changes when it raises all of its inputs by the same proportion in the long run.
- Diminishing marginal returns
- Diminishing marginal returns occur when adding more of one variable input to a fixed input makes each extra unit add less output.
Types of returns to scale
Can you name the three types of returns to scale?
Each type compares the rise in output with the rise in every input that caused it.
Increasing returns to scale occur when raising every input by a given proportion raises output by a larger proportion.
Can you think of an example?
A bottling firm doubles its staff, machines and floor space, and output rises from 10,000 to 25,000 bottles a week: inputs up 100 per cent, output up 150 per cent.
Constant returns to scale occur when raising every input by a given proportion raises output by exactly the same proportion.
Can you think of an example?
One typist with one computer types five letters an hour. Three typists with three computers type fifteen. Inputs and output have both tripled.
Decreasing returns to scale occur when raising every input by a given proportion raises output by a smaller proportion.
Can you think of an example?
A call centre doubles its staff, desks and phone lines, but calls answered rise only from 2,000 to 3,000 a day, a 50 per cent rise, because supervisors struggle to coordinate the larger team.
Check yourself
A firm raises its labour, machinery and land by 20 per cent, and its output rises by 12 per cent. What is it experiencing?
Output can grow faster or slower than the inputs that make it
In the long run every factor of production is variable, so a firm can scale up its labour, machines and buildings together. A bigger operation lets workers specialise in narrower tasks and makes large, specialised equipment worth buying. Geometry helps too: a pipe that takes twice the material to make carries four times the volume of liquid. These give increasing returns. Push growth far enough and the firm becomes hard to manage: layers of managers must pass information to workers and to each other, failures to communicate disrupt the flow of work, and output grows by a smaller proportion than the inputs.
A firm doubles all its inputs, paying the same price for each, and its output triples. What do you think happens to its average cost?
Doubling every input at unchanged prices doubles total cost, but output triples, so each unit now costs two-thirds of what it did before.
With input prices fixed, returns to scale set the slope of long-run average cost
Suppose the firm pays the same price for each input however much it buys. Raising every input by 10 per cent then raises total cost by 10 per cent, and average cost is total cost divided by output. With increasing returns, output rises by more than 10 per cent, so average cost falls: economies of scale. With constant returns, output rises by exactly 10 per cent and average cost does not change, the flat part of the long-run average cost curve. With decreasing returns, output rises by less, so average cost rises: diseconomies of scale.
Check yourself
A firm doubles every input, paying the same price for each. Its total cost rises from £20,000 to £40,000 and its output from 2,000 to 5,000 units. What is its new average cost?
£8
£40,000 ÷ 5,000 = £8, down from £20,000 ÷ 2,000 = £10. Output more than doubled when every input doubled: increasing returns to scale, so economies of scale.
Aren't decreasing returns to scale just diminishing marginal returns?
No. Diminishing marginal returns belong to the short run, where one input such as labour increases while others such as capital stay fixed. Returns to scale belong to the long run, where all inputs increase together. So a firm can meet diminishing marginal returns when it adds workers to one factory, and still enjoy increasing returns to scale when it builds a bigger factory and staffs it in proportion.
Define each type by output, then carry it through to cost: "every input doubled and output more than doubled, so with input prices unchanged average cost fell, an economy of scale." Then add the condition. Economies of scale can also come from cheaper inputs, such as bulk-buying discounts, with no change in returns to scale.
Check yourself
A firm pays the same price for its inputs however much it buys. Match each point on its long-run average cost curve to the returns to scale it shows.
Point A: Increasing returns to scale. Average cost is falling at A. With input prices fixed, that means output is growing by a larger proportion than the inputs.
Point B: Constant returns to scale. B is on the flat part. Output grows in proportion to the inputs, so cost per unit stays the same.
Point C: Decreasing returns to scale. Average cost is rising at C. With input prices fixed, that means output is growing by a smaller proportion than the inputs.
Check yourself
A supermarket chain doubles every input it uses, from shops to staff, and sells exactly twice as much, yet its average cost falls. What explains the fall?
Exam question
Explain the difference between increasing returns to scale and economies of scale. [4]
Increasing returns to scale is about physical output: when all inputs rise by a given proportion, output rises by a larger proportion. Economies of scale are about cost: average cost falls as the scale of output rises. If input prices stay the same, increasing returns cause economies of scale, because total cost rises in proportion to the inputs while output rises faster. But economies of scale can also come from cheaper inputs, such as bulk-buying discounts, even with constant returns to scale.
One mark for defining increasing returns by output, one for defining economies of scale by average cost, one for the link through unchanged input prices, and one for a source of economies of scale that is not increasing returns, such as bulk buying.
Returns to scale compare the rise in output with a rise in every input by the same proportion, so they belong to the long run. Output rising by a larger proportion is increasing returns, by the same proportion constant returns, and by a smaller proportion decreasing returns. With input prices unchanged, they give the long-run average cost curve its falling, flat and rising parts: economies of scale, constant cost and diseconomies of scale. Diminishing marginal returns are a different, short-run idea.