- Price discrimination
- Price discrimination is charging different customers different prices for the same product, where the gap between the prices does not come from a gap in costs.
- Product differentiation
- Product differentiation is making a product distinctive from its competitors' through its physical features, its location, intangible extras or what buyers believe about it.
Conditions for price discrimination
Can you name the three conditions for price discrimination?
Charging separate groups separate prices, called third-degree price discrimination, works only when all three hold at once.
Market power is a firm's ability to set its own price rather than take the market price as given, as a price taker must.
Can you think of an example?
A wheat farmer among thousands cannot charge any buyer more than the market price, because the buyer would go to another farmer. A train company running the only service on a route can.
Separable groups are buyers the firm can sort by their price elasticity of demand and tell apart, so it can charge the inelastic group more.
Can you think of an example?
Commuters must reach work on time, so their demand for peak trains is inelastic; leisure travellers can choose their train, so theirs is elastic. The company charges £60 for a peak return and £25 off-peak on the same route.
No resale means buyers who pay the low price cannot sell the product on to those charged the high price, or the price gap would close.
Can you think of an example?
An off-peak ticket is not valid on a peak train, so a commuter cannot buy the cheap ticket and use it at the busy time. A student cinema ticket is checked against a student card at the door.
Check yourself
Why can a theme park charge adults more than children for the same day ticket, but a greengrocer cannot charge some buyers more for the same apples?
Charging each group what it will pay raises the firm's profit
A single price leaves money on the table twice over. Buyers who would have paid more keep the difference, and buyers who would have paid a little less go without. Charging the keen buyers more and the reluctant ones less captures some of both, so the firm can sell more and earns more. The closer it can judge each buyer's willingness to pay, the more it can take.
One priceAt a single price P0 the firm sells Q0 and takes revenue R. Buyers who would have paid more keep the difference, and buyers who would pay a little less go without.
The firm charges more where demand is less elastic
With two groups and the same marginal cost of serving each, the firm treats each group as its own market. In each it sells up to the point where marginal revenue equals marginal cost, then reads the price off that group's demand curve. Where demand is less price elastic, as for commuters, marginal revenue falls away steeply, so the firm sells fewer units at a higher price. Where demand is more elastic, as for leisure travellers, it sells more units at a lower price.
Market 1Demand in market 1, D1, is less elastic. MR1 meets MC at Q1, and D1 gives the price there, P1.
Check yourself
Demand in market 1 is less price elastic than in market 2, and marginal cost is the same in both. Which point shows the price the firm charges in market 1?
Yes. MR1 meets MC at this quantity, and the price is read up on the demand curve D1, the most buyers in market 1 will pay for that many units.
This is where MR1 meets MC, which fixes how many units to sell in market 1. The price is read off demand above it, not off marginal revenue.
This is the price in market 2, where demand is more elastic, so it is the lower of the two prices, not the one charged in market 1.
A higher price that reflects a higher cost is not discrimination
Delivery to a remote island costs more because the van travels further, and a longer taxi ride costs more because it takes more fuel and time. In both cases the price follows the cost of supplying that buyer. Price discrimination is the case where the same product, costing the same to supply, sells to different buyers at different prices because they will pay different amounts.
Check yourself
Three of these are price discrimination. Which one is not?
Isn't price discrimination always bad for consumers?
No. The lower price can bring in buyers who would not have paid the single price at all, so output rises and those buyers gain, such as students and pensioners travelling off-peak. The buyers who lose are the ones in the inelastic group, who pay more. The harm is greatest where the firm faces little competition, or where the pricing is hard for buyers to see and compare.
State the three conditions in order: market power, separable groups with different elasticities, no resale. Then apply each to the case in the question. "Students show a card, so the cinema can tell the groups apart" is application; the bare list is not. For evaluation, say who gains and who loses: the elastic group pays less, the inelastic group more.
Check yourself
A firm used to charge one price, P0. It now also sells at a lower price, P2, to buyers who would not pay P0, and stops them reselling. Which area is the revenue it gains from those buyers?
A is extra revenue from the keenest buyers, charged P1, above P0. They were buying already, so it is not revenue from new buyers.
C is the revenue from the single price P0 on the first Q0 units, which the firm was taking before it split its buyers.
Yes. B is the lower price P2 times the extra units sold between Q0 and Q2, to buyers who would have gone without at P0.
Exam question
Explain the conditions a firm needs in order to price discriminate. [3]
It needs market power, so it can set its own price rather than take the market price; it must separate buyers into groups with different price elasticities of demand, so it can charge the inelastic group more; and it must stop resale between the groups, or the cheap group would sell on to the dear one.
One mark for each condition, each linked to why it matters. Naming the groups' different price elasticities, rather than just different buyers, marks the answer out as third-degree price discrimination.
Price discrimination is charging different customers different prices for the same product when the gap is not explained by cost. Firms do it to raise profit by charging each group what it will pay. It needs market power, groups with different price elasticities that the firm can tell apart, and no resale. It can raise output and help price-sensitive buyers, and it harms consumers most where competition is weak or the pricing is hidden.