- Redistribution
- Redistribution is taking income from those with higher incomes and providing income to those with lower incomes, through taxes and benefits.
- Progressive tax
- A progressive tax is one whose rates increase as income increases, so the rich pay a higher share of their income than the poor.
Policies that reduce inequality
Can you name the four kinds of policy this page sets out for reducing inequality?
Each moves income or opportunity toward the worse off.
Progressive taxation is a tax system whose rates rise as income rises, so people with higher incomes pay a larger share of their income in tax.
Can you think of an example?
Income tax in England charges nothing on a personal allowance, then a basic, a higher and an additional rate on each slice above set thresholds.
Cash benefits are payments from the state to households, such as those on low incomes, funded from taxes.
Can you think of an example?
Universal Credit tops up the income of a low-paid worker or someone out of work, using money raised in tax.
A ladder of opportunity is public spending on schools, training and support for students in need, so each child has a fair chance whatever their family.
Can you think of an example?
Free state schooling and apprenticeships aim to let a child from a poor family reach the same job as an equally able richer child.
Inheritance tax is a tax on the value of what a person leaves when they die, which limits how much wealth passes to the next generation.
Can you think of an example?
An estate that includes shares worth a large sum pays inheritance tax on its value above the tax-free threshold, so less wealth passes on untouched.
Cash benefits and direct taxes cut UK income inequality by almost a third
The ONS measures inequality before and after the state steps in. In the financial year ending 2024, the Gini coefficient of original income was 47.6 per cent. Cash benefits brought it down to 37.3 per cent, and direct taxes such as income tax to 32.9 per cent. After all taxes and benefits the richest fifth had 3.3 times the income of the poorest fifth, against 12.2 times before.
Check yourself
The Gini coefficient of UK household income is 47.6 per cent before taxes and benefits and 32.9 per cent after cash benefits and direct taxes. What does the fall show?
Heavy redistribution weakens the reward for working
Policies to reduce inequality, if carried to extremes, can injure incentives for economic output. Very high taxes on the rich would be likely to discourage work and entrepreneurship. The poverty trap is the same problem at the bottom: if a benefit is cut by a pound for every pound earned, working leaves a person no better off. On this view, more equality always costs output.
Check yourself
A household gets a benefit of £100 a week, cut by £1 for every £1 it earns. One adult takes a job paying £60 a week. How much better off is the household?
Declared income responds most to tax rates at the top
HMRC studied Scotland's income tax changes of 2018 to 2019, which set Scottish rates apart from the rest of the UK. It found little to no change in declared income at the starter, basic and intermediate rates, some at the higher rate, and the most at the top rate, where taxpayers can cut their hours or plan their tax. Most results were not statistically significant, but the response generally rose with income.
Some policies raise equality and output together, up to a point
That view may be too pessimistic. Free state schooling is redistributive, since children from low-income families receive schooling worth more than their families pay in tax, yet a well-educated workforce helps the economy grow. Rich countries with similar incomes have different levels of inequality, so over a middle range equality can change with little effect on output. Only a much bigger push reduces output.
A trade-offMoving from A to B buys more equality with less output all the way along.
Name the policy before you weigh it: a higher top rate of income tax, a bigger benefit and free schooling carry different costs. Give evidence each way, the fall in the Gini for, the poverty trap and top earners' response against, then judge by the policy and how far it goes.
Check yourself
The curve shows economic output at each level of equality. At which point would a further move toward equality cause the biggest fall in output?
At A the curve slopes upward, so more equality comes with more output, as when free schooling builds the skills of children from poorer families.
At B the curve is almost flat, so equality can rise with little change in output: the middle range where rich countries differ in inequality.
Yes. At C the curve falls steeply, so a further push toward equality costs output, as very high taxes weaken the reward for work and enterprise.
Exam question
Evaluate the view that the UK government should reduce income inequality by raising the top rate of income tax. [8]
A higher top rate is progressive: it takes a larger share from the highest incomes, and the revenue can fund cash benefits or schooling, which the ONS shows narrow inequality; cash benefits and direct taxes cut the Gini from 47.6 to 32.9 per cent. But very high taxes on the rich may discourage work and enterprise, and HMRC found declared income responds most among top-rate taxpayers, so the extra revenue may be smaller than planned. Spending on schooling may raise equality and output together. Judgement: a modest rise may narrow inequality at little cost, but the further it is pushed, the more the top earners' response eats into both revenue and output.
Two marks for how the tax narrows inequality, two for the incentive cost with evidence, two for an alternative or the size of the effect, and two for a judgement that names what the answer turns on: here, how far the rate is raised.
Progressive taxes and cash benefits move income from richer to poorer households, a ladder of opportunity widens chances, and inheritance tax limits inherited wealth. In the UK, cash benefits and direct taxes cut the Gini coefficient by almost a third. Pushed hard, redistribution weakens the reward for work, most of all at the top, but schooling can raise equality and output together. The judgement turns on the policy and how far it is pushed.