- Long-run equilibrium
- A perfectly competitive market is in long-run equilibrium when no new firms want to enter and existing firms do not want to leave, as supernormal profits have gone.
- Price taker
- A price taker is a firm that must accept the prevailing equilibrium price in its market, because the pressure of competing firms forces it to.
Short-run outcomes for a price taker
Can you name the three short-run outcomes for a perfectly competitive firm?
The firm produces where P = MR = MC, and where the market price falls against its cost curves decides what it earns.
Supernormal profit in the short run is when the market price is above the lowest point of average total cost, so price exceeds average cost at the chosen output.
Can you think of an example?
Demand for oat milk surges and the market price rises to £1.20 a carton. A farm making 10,000 cartons at an average cost of £1 earns £2,000 above normal profit.
A loss but stay open is when price is below average total cost but above average variable cost, so revenue covers every variable cost and part of the fixed cost.
Can you think of an example?
The price falls to 90p, below the farm's average cost of £1.05 but above its average variable cost of 70p. Staying open loses less than shutting down, while its fixed costs must be paid.
Shut down is when price falls below the lowest point of average variable cost, so producing adds more to cost than to revenue and the firm stops producing.
Can you think of an example?
The price falls to 60p, below the lowest average variable cost of 65p. Each carton made loses money even before rent, so the farm stops producing and pays only its fixed costs.
Check yourself
A perfectly competitive firm's price is £4. At its best output, average total cost is £5 and average variable cost is £3. What should it do in the short run?
Firms in a perfectly competitive market are earning supernormal profit. Nothing stops new firms joining. What do you think happens to the market price?
Profit draws in new firms, and each adds to market supply. The supply curve shifts right, and the price falls. Entry carries on until the profit that attracted it has gone.
ProfitMarket demand D and supply S1 set the price P1. At that price firms earn supernormal profit.
New firms enter and market supply shifts right from S1 to S2, so the price falls from P1 to P2 and quantity rises from Q1 to Q2.
- No single firm can change the market price. But many firms entering together shift the market supply curve, and that does change it.
- Entry carries on as long as there are still profits to be had, pushing supply further right and the price further down.
- It stops when the price reaches the lowest point of each firm's average total cost, P2, where no firm earns supernormal profit.
Short runAt P1 the firm produces q1, where P1 = MC. Price is above ATC there, so area A is supernormal profit.
The price line each firm faces moves down from P1 to P2, so it cuts output from q1 to q2, where P2 just touches the bottom of ATC.
- Each firm is a price taker, so its demand curve is flat at the market price: P = AR = MR. It produces where that line meets marginal cost.
- At P1 price is above average total cost at q1, so the rectangle between them is supernormal profit. At P2 price equals average total cost at q2: normal profit only.
- Losses work in reverse. Firms exit, market supply shifts left, and the price rises back to the bottom of ATC.
- Price equals marginal cost in the short and long run, so the firm is always allocatively efficient. Only in the long run does it also produce at minimum ATC, which is productive efficiency.
Check yourself
Which point shows this perfectly competitive firm in long-run equilibrium?
A is the lowest point of MC. A price that low is below average variable cost, so the firm would shut down there.
Yes. B is where MC cuts ATC at its lowest point: price there equals minimum average cost, so only normal profit is earned and entry stops.
C is on MC above ATC, so a price that high brings supernormal profit, and new firms would still be entering.
Why doesn't one firm cut its price to win more customers?
Because it has no reason to. A price taker can already sell as much as it wishes at the market price, so a lower price would only lose it revenue. And it cannot charge more, because buyers would switch to the many other firms selling the same product. What moves the price is market supply as a whole, which changes when many firms enter or leave at once.
Draw two diagrams side by side with the same price on both axes: the market on one side, the firm on the other. Shift market supply, carry the new price across to the firm as a flat P = AR = MR line, then mark q where it cuts MC. In the long run the price line just touches the bottom of ATC.
Check yourself
Firms in a perfectly competitive market are making losses, and some leave in the long run. Which way does market supply move?
Exam question
Using diagrams, explain how a perfectly competitive market moves from short-run supernormal profit to long-run equilibrium. [4]
At the high price P1 each firm produces where P = MC and price is above ATC, so it earns supernormal profit. With no barriers, new firms enter, market supply shifts right and the price falls. Entry continues until the price reaches P2 at the lowest point of ATC, where each firm earns only normal profit and produces where P = MC = minimum ATC.
One mark for the profit shown against ATC, one for entry with no barriers, one for market supply shifting right and price falling, and one for the new price at minimum ATC with normal profit.
A perfectly competitive firm is a price taker: it faces a flat demand curve at the market price and produces where P = MR = MC. In the short run it can earn supernormal profit or make a loss. Profits draw in new firms and losses drive firms out, shifting market supply until the price sits at the lowest point of average total cost, where every firm earns normal profit.