- Nudge
- A nudge is a change to the way a choice is presented that steers people towards one option without banning any option or changing its price.
- Regulation
- Regulation is a rule backed by law that requires or forbids a choice and punishes those who break it, such as a workplace smoking ban.
Tools of choice architecture
Can you name the four tools of choice architecture on the A-level specification?
Choice architecture is the design of the setting in which people choose; each tool changes that setting, not any price.
A default choice is the option people end up with if they do nothing, so whoever sets it steers what most people get.
Can you think of an example?
Automatic enrolment puts eligible UK employees into a workplace pension unless they opt out, so staying in takes no action.
Framing is presenting the same information differently, such as a small daily sum instead of a yearly one, to change the choice made.
Can you think of an example?
A gym sells membership at £1 a day rather than £365 a year: the same cost, in a figure that sounds smaller.
Mandated choice is requiring an active yes-or-no decision before people can go on, so nobody drifts into an option by doing nothing.
Can you think of an example?
A joining form will not submit until the new starter ticks yes or no to the cycle-to-work scheme, so nobody misses out by forgetting.
Restricted choice is cutting the number of options on offer so that a long list does not stop people choosing well.
Can you think of an example?
A workplace pension offers three investment funds rather than two hundred, so savers can compare them all.
Check yourself
A council's online form for new households will not go through until the household ticks yes or no to garden-waste collection. Which tool of choice architecture is this?
Automatic enrolment made pension saving the default, and most workers stayed in
People who mean to save often put it off, but a default does not wait. Automatic enrolment, introduced in 2012 to make long-term saving the norm, puts eligible employees into a workplace pension, and each keeps the right to opt out so the decision to save stays theirs. Among employers with an automatic-enrolment scheme, nine per cent of those enrolled in 2018/19 opted out within a month; by 2024 around nine in ten eligible employees were saving into one.
Check yourself
Automatic enrolment is set up by law and places a duty on employers. What makes it a nudge, rather than regulation, for the worker?
A tax letter telling people that others pay brought more payments in
The government's Behavioural Insights Team ran a trial with HMRC in which 140,000 taxpayers were sent either the old-style letter or a new one saying nine out of ten people in Britain pay their tax on time, some naming their town. With the old-style letter, 67.5 per cent had responded within three months; with the letter naming their town, 83.0 per cent had. A later trial that changed only the social-norm line raised payment rates from 38.7 to 45.5 per cent.
A default can also hold savers at the minimum
Inertia is one reason people stay at the default rate. The DWP found in 2025 that around three in ten private-sector savers in defined contribution schemes save at exactly the minimum, a total of eight per cent of qualifying earnings from employer and employee together, and that most low earners save little beyond it. A minimum set too low stays low.
A nudge suits choices people want to make, and regulation suits harm to others
A nudge works on people who want the outcome and keep putting it off, such as saving; it is cheap and leaves the choice with them. It does least where people have firmly decided or the cost falls on others: a firm whose waste harms people downstream is not moved by a form's layout, and a ban, a tax or a legal limit does more. Someone still decides which way people are steered.
Name the tool and give the mechanism: "automatic enrolment makes saving the default, so inertia keeps workers in" earns more than "nudges change behaviour". Then set the evidence against its limits, and say which choices a nudge suits and where regulation does more.
Check yourself
Three of these are nudges. Which one is not?
Exam question
Assess whether a nudge is a better way than regulation to raise pension saving in the UK. [8]
Automatic enrolment is a default: workers are put into a workplace pension and can opt out. Inertia and bounded self-control mean people who mean to save put it off, so a default works where a reminder does not, and by 2024 around nine in ten eligible employees were saving. It is cheap and keeps the choice with the worker. But inertia also holds people at the default rate: around three in ten private-sector savers save at exactly the minimum, and most low earners save little beyond it. Compulsion would reach those who opt out, but would take the choice from people who have good reason to save less. On balance a nudge suits pension saving because most people want to save, but the default rate has to be set high enough to be adequate.
Levels reward the mechanism of the default, evidence on participation, a developed limit such as savers left at the minimum, and a comparison with compulsory saving. The top level needs a judgement that follows from both sides and says what it depends on, such as where the default rate is set.
A nudge changes how a choice is presented without banning any option or changing its price. Automatic enrolment made pension saving the default, and an HMRC letter saying most people pay on time raised payments. But a default also holds many savers at the minimum, and where people have firmly decided or others bear the harm, regulation does more.