- Normal profit
- Normal profit is the minimum profit an owner must expect to earn to keep their resources in the business, and economists count it as a cost.
- Supernormal profit
- Supernormal profit is any profit above normal profit, where total revenue exceeds total cost including both explicit and implicit costs.
The costs and profits an economist counts
Can you name the two kinds of cost and the two kinds of profit an economist counts?
Normal profit only makes sense once the owner's own resources are counted as a cost.
Explicit costs are out-of-pocket costs, the actual payments a firm makes, such as the wages it pays its staff or the rent on its premises.
Can you think of an example?
Sam's café pays £30,000 a year in rent and £90,000 for staff and stock. Both sums leave its bank account.
Implicit costs are the opportunity cost of using resources the firm already owns, often ones its owner contributes.
Can you think of an example?
Sam left a £40,000 job to run the café and draws no formal salary. The £40,000 she gives up is a cost, though no money changes hands.
Accounting profit is total revenue minus explicit costs only, the difference between the money brought in and the money paid out.
Can you think of an example?
The café takes £150,000 a year, so its accounting profit is £150,000 − £120,000 = £30,000. Its tax bill is based on this figure.
Economic profit is total revenue minus total cost, including both explicit and implicit costs.
Can you think of an example?
Take off the £40,000 salary Sam gave up as well, and her economic profit is £30,000 − £40,000 = −£10,000, less than normal profit.
Check yourself
Three of these firms are earning supernormal profit. Which one is earning only normal profit?
Supernormal profit draws in rivals until only normal profit is left
When firms in a competitive market earn economic profits, new firms are drawn in, market supply shifts right and the price falls. Entry continues as long as there are profits, and stops when the price reaches the zero-profit level. Losses work in reverse through exit. Once only normal profit is left, no firm wants to enter or leave.
Supernormal profitAt price P1 each firm makes Q1, where marginal cost meets the price. Price is above average cost there, so the shaded area A is supernormal profit.
Check yourself
Firms in a market with no barriers to entry are earning supernormal profit. What happens in the long run?
Can you work out what revenue would give Sam exactly normal profit?
Keep Sam's costs the same. Revenue of £160,000 gives an accounting profit of £40,000 and an economic profit of zero: exactly normal profit, since the café pays her what her old job did. Revenue of £170,000 gives an economic profit of £10,000, which is supernormal.
If a firm is only making normal profit, isn't it making no money?
No. Zero economic profit usually still leaves a positive accounting profit, large enough to pay the owner exactly what their time and money would earn in their next best use. Normal profit is counted as a cost because, without it, the owner would close the business and go elsewhere. A firm on normal profit is doing as well as it could anywhere else, and no better.
Classify by comparing revenue with cost, and say which cost you mean. Average revenue above average cost is supernormal profit; equal is normal profit; below is a loss. On a diagram the average cost curve already includes normal profit, so a price that just touches it means normal profit, not zero income.
Check yourself
Firms in this market earn supernormal profit at price P1, and nothing stops new firms entering. At which point does each firm end up once entry has stopped?
A is where each firm produces at today's price P1, earning supernormal profit. That profit draws rivals in, so the price does not stay at P1.
Yes. B is the bottom of average total cost. Entry pushes the price down until it just covers average cost here, which leaves only normal profit.
C is the lowest point of marginal cost. A price that low would not cover average cost, so firms would make losses and some would leave.
Exam question
A self-employed plumber makes an accounting profit of £35,000 a year. She could earn £38,000 as an employee. Explain whether she earns normal profit, supernormal profit or less than normal profit. [2]
Less than normal profit. Her economic profit is £35,000 − £38,000, a loss of £3,000, because the £38,000 she gives up is an implicit cost.
One mark for the label and one for counting the forgone salary as a cost. Her accounting profit is positive, and she still earns £3,000 less than her next best use of her time.
Accounting profit takes only explicit costs from revenue. Economic profit also takes implicit costs, such as the salary an owner gives up. Normal profit is what the owner could earn elsewhere, counted as a cost, so a firm earning exactly normal profit makes zero economic profit. Economic profit above zero is supernormal profit. In a competitive market it attracts new firms, and entry pushes the price down until only normal profit is left.