- Negative externality
- A negative externality is a cost that an exchange between a buyer and a seller imposes on a third party who is not part of the exchange.
- Positive externality
- A positive externality is a benefit that an exchange between a buyer and a seller brings to a third party who does not pay for it.
Private, external and social cost
Can you name the three kinds of cost on an externality diagram?
These are costs of production: private and social cost are curves, and external cost is the gap between them. When the harm comes from consuming a good, as with passive smoke, marginal social benefit lies below marginal private benefit instead, and the market again over-consumes.
Private costs are the costs of production that a firm itself incurs and pays, such as its labour and material costs.
Can you think of an example?
The last fridge the free market makes costs its maker £650 in labour, parts and materials. Market supply is the marginal private cost (MPC) curve.
External costs are the costs of production that fall on third parties, unpaid by the firm; per unit, they are the gap between MSC and MPC.
Can you think of an example?
Pollution from making each fridge does £100 of damage to people living near the factories. The makers pay none of it, so none of it shows in the price.
Social costs are the full costs of production to society: the private costs a firm incurs plus the external costs that pass on to others.
Can you think of an example?
The last fridge the free market makes costs its maker £650 and does £100 of damage, so its social cost is £750. Buyers value it at only £650, so society loses £100 on that fridge.
The marketFirms supply on their private costs, so the market settles where MPC meets demand, at P1 and Q1.
Adding the external cost puts MSC above MPC, so the optimum price is up at P2 rather than P1 and quantity is Q2, below Q1.
- Firms supply on their private costs, so the market settles at P1 and Q1, where marginal private cost (MPC) meets demand.
- Adding the external cost of each unit to MPC gives the marginal social cost (MSC) curve, which lies above MPC by that external cost.
- With no external benefit, demand shows both the private and the social benefit to buyers (MSB). MSC meets demand at P2 and Q2: a higher price and a lower quantity, with less pollution.
- A Pigouvian tax, a tax on each unit equal to its external cost, makes firms pay the full social cost, so supply shifts up from MPC to MSC and the market settles at P2 and Q2.
Check yourself
Production of this good pollutes the air. Which point is the social optimum?
A is where MPC meets demand. Firms count only their private costs there, so it is the free-market outcome, with too much output.
B is where MSC meets demand, so every cost is counted, including the one borne by third parties. That is the social optimum.
C is on MSC at the market quantity. It shows the full social cost of the last unit made, which is more than buyers value it at.
The market makes Q1 and the optimum is Q2. On the diagram, which area do you think shows the welfare loss?
The loss is only on the extra units from Q2 to Q1, and on each it is what the unit costs society, on MSC, minus what buyers value it at, on demand. The external cost on units up to Q2 is outweighed by their benefit.
The optimumCounting every cost, society wants Q2, where MSC meets demand, at price P2.
Left alone, the market moves right past the optimum, from Q2 to Q1, and the price falls from P2 to P1.
- Every unit between Q2 and Q1 costs society more to make, on the MSC curve, than buyers value it at, on the demand curve. At the market output, social costs of production exceed social benefits to consumers.
- The welfare loss, also called deadweight loss, is the sum of those losses: the triangle between MSC and demand from Q2 to Q1. Its point sits at the optimum, Q2, and its widest side at the market quantity, Q1.
Check yourself
Smoke from a cement works dirties the washing of households nearby. Compared with the social optimum, what does the free market in cement do?
Doesn't pollution make the market price too high?
No, too low. The market price covers only the firm's private costs, so buyers pay less than the full cost of what they use, and they buy more than they would at the full cost. Counting the external cost gives a higher price and a lower quantity. The fault in the market is too much output at too low a price.
Label the curves MPC, MSC and D = MPB = MSB, and mark both quantities. Say which is which: Q1 where MPC meets demand is the market output, Q2 where MSC meets demand is the optimum. Shade the welfare loss triangle between MSC and demand from Q2 to Q1, pointing at the optimum, and name the third party who bears the cost.
Check yourself
A fridge market settles at £650 and 45,000 fridges. Each fridge causes £100 of pollution damage. Counting it, the optimum is £700 and 40,000 fridges. The curves are straight lines. What is the welfare loss, in pounds?
£250000
The triangle runs from 40,000 to 45,000 fridges, a base of 5,000. At 45,000 its height is the £100 gap between MSC and demand. So ½ × 5,000 × £100 = £250,000.
Check yourself
Which of these is a negative externality from consumption rather than from production?
Exam question
Using a diagram, explain why a free market in a good whose production causes pollution leads to a misallocation of resources. [4]
Firms supply on their marginal private cost and ignore the pollution cost to third parties, so the market settles where MPC meets demand at Q1. The marginal social cost, MPC plus the external cost, lies above MPC and meets demand at the lower optimum Q2. Between Q2 and Q1 each unit's social cost exceeds its benefit, so the market over-produces and there is a welfare loss triangle between MSC and demand.
One mark each for: firms ignore the external cost; MSC above MPC; market output Q1 above the optimum Q2; the welfare loss shown between MSC and demand from Q2 to Q1. Stating over-production with no reason for it earns one mark at most.
Firms supply on their private costs and ignore the external cost, so the market price is too low and the quantity too high. Counting the external cost puts marginal social cost above marginal private cost, and the optimum comes at a higher price and a lower quantity. On the units between the two quantities, social cost exceeds benefit, and that excess is the welfare loss. A Pigouvian tax equal to the external cost per unit makes firms pay it, and moves the market to the optimum.