- Microfinance
- Microfinance is the provision of financial services, such as small loans and savings accounts, to poor people whom ordinary banks do not serve.
- Micro-credit
- Micro-credit is the lending side of microfinance: small loans, usually charging interest, made to poor households, borrowing groups or tiny firms.
Banks lend against collateral and a credit record, which the poorest lack
Before a bank makes a loan, it checks the borrower's income and past borrowing. It may also require collateral, often property or equipment it could seize and sell if the loan is not repaid, or a cosigner who pledges to repay. The poorest households in low-income countries seldom have any of these.
In those countries incomes are spent at once on necessities such as food, and the lack of saving means a lack of funds for investment. Research by the economists Abhijit Banerjee and Esther Duflo finds households trapped in low incomes because they cannot muster enough investment to push themselves out of poverty.
Supporters see small loans letting the poor invest their way out of poverty
Microfinance lenders make small loans, often at interest rates of 25 per cent or more, and more recently offer savings accounts, insurance and money transfers too. Supporters see it as a market-based way to cut poverty: a loan lets a poor household invest in a business, tools or stock.
A review of the evidence from sub-Saharan Africa, published in 2010 for the UK's Department for International Development (DFID), found benefits. Micro-credit and micro-savings raised poor people's savings, spending, assets and housing, and generally improved their health. There was some evidence that clients were better placed to deal with shocks, though not everywhere.
Check yourself
Why do banks seldom lend to the poorest households in low-income countries?
The same review found that micro-credit made some borrowers poorer
The 2010 review also concluded that some people are made poorer, not richer, by microfinance, particularly those who borrow. Some consume the loan instead of investing it. Some businesses fail to earn enough profit to pay the high interest. And the conditions borrowers live in are, by definition, fragile.
The review found much evidence that micro-credit may be damaging the schooling of borrowers' children, as families struggle to pay school costs, and almost no sign that it creates jobs. It suggested focusing loans on entrepreneurs rather than treating every poor person as one.
Weak evidence leaves the size of any benefit uncertain
A second DFID review, published in 2011, found that almost all impact evaluations of microfinance suffer from weak methods and inadequate data, so their estimates of its effects are unreliable. It warned that this can lead to misconceptions about what a programme achieves, and divert attention from interventions that may do more for the poor.
The 2010 review judged that micro-savings may be a better model than micro-credit. A saver owes no interest, so needs no rise in income to keep up, and failure costs less. It added that the evidence on savings is small and needs more rigorous evaluation.
Check yourself
Why did the 2010 review judge micro-savings a safer model than micro-credit?
Start with why the poor are shut out of banks: no collateral or credit record. Give the case for with the sub-Saharan Africa review's gains in savings, assets and health, and the case against with borrowers made poorer by high interest. Judge by naming what success depends on: lending to real entrepreneurs, savings as well as loans, and better evidence.
Check yourself
Which conclusion about microfinance fits the evidence on this page?
Exam question
Evaluate the view that microfinance is an effective way to reduce poverty in developing countries. [4]
For: the poorest lack collateral and a credit record, so banks will not lend to them; small loans let them invest, and a 2010 DFID review of sub-Saharan Africa found gains in savings, assets, housing and health. Against: the same review found some borrowers made poorer by high interest rates and failed businesses, and a 2011 DFID review found most evaluations too weak to be reliable. Judgement: it helps most when lending goes to real entrepreneurs and savings are offered as well as loans.
One mark for why the poor cannot borrow from banks, one for evidence of benefits, one for evidence of harm or weak evidence, and one for a judgement that names what success depends on.
Microfinance offers small loans and savings accounts to people banks will not serve, because they lack collateral or a credit record. Supporters see it letting the poor invest their way out of poverty. A 2010 review for DFID found gains in savings, assets, housing and health, but also found that some borrowers are made poorer, particularly by high interest rates. A 2011 review found almost all evaluations too weak to be reliable. Micro-savings may be the safer model, though its evidence is small.