Learn › Economic theory › When markets fail

When markets fail

Merit and demerit goods

Tell a merit good from a demerit good, and both from a public good

Specification: AQA 4.1.8.5 Edexcel 1.3.4

Key terms
Merit good
A merit good is a good that a free market under-consumes, because buyers underestimate its benefit to themselves or ignore its benefit to others.
Demerit good
A demerit good is a good that a free market over-consumes, because buyers underestimate its harm to themselves or ignore its cost to others.

Why a market gets the quantity wrong

Can you name the three causes that make a market get the quantity of a good wrong?

Any one of the three, or several together, can make a good a merit or demerit good.

Check yourself

Sugary drinks are cheap in shops, and many buyers underestimate the tooth decay and weight gain they cause. How would an economist classify them, and why?

Buyers of a merit good count only their own benefit, so too little is bought

Market demand for flu jabs reflects only the benefits the people vaccinated receive. The market does not recognise the benefit to others, so the jabs are under-produced and under-consumed. Education works the same way. It benefits the person who receives it, and a society where most people are well educated also gains better health, less crime and a more stable government. So many nations use taxpayers' money to subsidise schooling.

A merit good is under-consumedVertical axis: Price, costs and benefits. Horizontal axis: Quantity of flu jabs. MPC: an upward-sloping line. MPB: a downward-sloping line. MSB: a downward-sloping line. MPB meets MPC, at quantity Q1. MSB meets MPC, at quantity Q*. Shaded area W: welfare loss.WQ1Q*MPCMPB
Demand counts only the benefit to the people vaccinated, MPB, so the market stops at Q1. Counting the benefit to others, MSB, the optimum is Q*. Area W is the welfare loss from the jabs not bought.

A market supplies merit and demerit goods in the wrong amount, but a public good not at all

Merit and demerit goods are rival and excludable: a vaccine dose given to one person cannot go to another, and a shop can refuse anyone who will not pay. So a market supplies them, in the wrong quantity. A public good is non-excludable and non-rival, so free riders can stop a market supplying it at all. To sort a good, ask first whether non-payers can be kept out, then whether buyers misjudge it or ignore its effect on others.

Check yourself

Education benefits the person who receives it, and a well-educated society also gains better health and less crime. Why does a free market provide too little of it?

Example

Can you think of a merit good someone might go without, even though its full benefit is more than it costs?

Common mistake

Isn't a merit good just anything that is good for you?

No. Bread is good for you, but buyers judge its benefit well and it spills over onto nobody else, so a market provides about the right amount. A merit good is one the free market under-consumes, because people misjudge its benefit to themselves or ignore its benefit to others. The label is also a value judgement: someone has decided what the right amount is, and economists can disagree. Overriding adults' own choices for their good is paternalism, which critics reject.

Exam tip

Classify, then give the cause and the direction: "a demerit good, over-consumed because smokers underestimate the harm and passive smoking hurts third parties". Then match the policy to the direction: a subsidy or free provision for a merit good, such as NHS vaccinations or state schooling; a tax or a ban for a demerit good, such as tobacco duty or the soft drinks industry levy.

Check yourself

Three of these are usually classed as merit goods. Which one is a public good?

Exam question

Explain why cigarettes are classed as a demerit good rather than a public good. [4]

What to take away

A merit good benefits the person who consumes it and spills benefits onto others, yet a free market under-consumes it: buyers ignore the benefit to third parties or underestimate their own. A demerit good is over-consumed, because buyers underestimate the harm or ignore the cost to others. Both are rival and excludable, so a market supplies them in the wrong quantity. A public good is non-excludable and non-rival, so a market may not supply it at all.