- Market economy
- A market economy is one where economic decisions are decentralised, private individuals own resources, and businesses supply goods and services based on demand.
- Command economy
- A command economy is one where economic decisions are passed down from government authority and the government owns the resources.
The case for each system
Can you name two advantages of a market economy and two of a command economy?
Two cases for markets, then two for planning.
Prices move as goods become scarcer or more plentiful, telling firms in a market economy what to make without any central planner.
Can you think of an example?
As demand for electric bikes grew, their prices and profits rose, and firms switched production to them without being told to.
Firms in a market economy keep the profit from a better or cheaper product, rewarding invention and cost-cutting.
Can you think of an example?
A supermarket that finds a cheaper way to move its stock can undercut rivals. A state firm with no rivals has no such spur.
A command economy decides who gets what, so it can share out essentials such as housing and healthcare more equally than markets would.
Can you think of an example?
A planner can guarantee every family a home and free medical care, which a low earner in a pure market might not afford.
A government that owns the resources can direct them at long-run goals, such as railways or power stations, faster than private firms might.
Can you think of an example?
The Soviet Union moved millions of people from farms into heavy industry within decades, at great human cost and with consumer goods scarce.
The two systems differ over who decides what to make, how, and for whom
In a command economy the government decides which goods and services are produced and what prices are charged for them, which methods of production are used and what workers are paid, and it owns the resources and the businesses. In a market economy those decisions are decentralised. Private individuals own and run the businesses, firms supply goods and services based on demand, and a person's income depends on how much society values what they produce.
Check yourself
Three of these are features of a command economy. Which one belongs to a market economy?
Most real economies are mixed
Most economies in the real world combine elements of command and market systems. No market is absolutely free: laws that protect property, enforce contracts, prevent fraud and collect taxes always set the rules of the game. Even the most command-oriented economies use markets, and heavily regulated ones grow underground markets where people trade without the government's approval. So the real choice is a balance between market freedom and government rules, and each economy sits somewhere along a spectrum.
Can you think of something in the UK that the state provides alongside private firms?
Most of what a UK household buys, a phone contract, a sandwich, a haircut, is produced by private firms responding to what customers want. Yet the NHS provides most healthcare free at the point of use, state schools are paid for from taxes, and the government sets a minimum wage. The UK is mixed, sitting towards the market end with a large public sector.
Check yourself
In an economy, private firms produce most goods for profit, while the state runs healthcare and schools from taxes. What kind of economy is it?
If a country has private businesses, isn't it a market economy?
Not on that evidence alone. Almost every economy has some private firms and some state provision, so the presence of either settles nothing. China has many private businesses and still sits closer to the command end of the spectrum, because the state owns many of the largest firms and banks and directs much of the country's investment. Ask who makes most of the decisions about what to produce, how, and for whom: households and firms, or the government.
Name the mechanism, not just the label: prices and private ownership for a market economy, state planning and ownership for a command one. Back a "mixed" answer with one example from each side. "The UK is mixed: most goods come from private firms, while the NHS is state-run and tax-funded" earns the marks that "the UK is mixed" does not.
Check yourself
A country has millions of private businesses, but the state owns most of its largest firms and banks and directs much of its investment. Where does it sit?
Exam question
Explain two differences between a market economy and a command economy. [4]
First, ownership: in a market economy private individuals own resources and businesses, while in a command economy the government owns them. Second, decisions: in a market economy firms decide what to produce and at what price in response to demand, while in a command economy the government decides output, prices and wages.
One mark for each difference identified and one for explaining each side of it. A difference stated for one system only, such as "the government decides", earns the first mark and not the second.
In a command economy the government owns the resources and decides what is produced, at what price, by what method and for what wage. In a market economy those decisions are decentralised: private owners run businesses and supply goods based on demand. Most real economies are mixed, combining market freedom with government rules and provision, and the useful question is where along the spectrum a country sits.