- Labour market flexibility
- Labour market flexibility is how easily the number of workers and hours, the tasks workers do and the wages they are paid can change as demand changes.
- Employment protection
- Employment protection is the set of legal rules, such as notice periods and redundancy pay, that make it costlier for firms to dismiss workers.
Kinds of labour market flexibility
Can you name three kinds of labour market flexibility?
Each lets a firm respond to demand in a different way.
Numerical flexibility is a firm's ability to change how many workers it uses, or their hours, through temporary, agency, part-time or zero-hours contracts.
Can you think of an example?
A Blackpool hotel takes on agency staff for the summer season and stops using them in October.
Functional flexibility is the ability of workers to move between different tasks within a firm, because they are trained in more than one skill.
Can you think of an example?
A supermarket trains its staff to run the tills, restock shelves and pick online orders, and moves them to wherever the work is that hour.
Wage flexibility is how easily pay rises or falls with the demand for labour, through performance pay, bonuses or local pay rates.
Can you think of an example?
A sales firm pays a basic wage plus commission, so its wage bill falls on its own when orders drop.
A wage that can fall lets firms keep more workers when demand drops
When the demand for labour falls, as in a recession, a flexible wage falls towards the new equilibrium and firms cut fewer jobs. In practice wages are sticky downward: minimum wage laws, contracts and employers' fear that pay cuts make staff work less hard or leave all hold them up. When wages are inflexible and unlikely to fall, the quantity of labour demanded drops further at the old wage, and unemployment results.
BeforeThe wage is W0 and Q0 workers are employed.
Check yourself
The demand for labour falls from D0 to D1, but the wage stays at W0. Which point shows how many workers are employed?
Yes. At W0 firms hire only what the new demand curve D1 shows, and nobody is employed unless a firm hires them.
B is where the wage would settle if it could fall. The wage is stuck at W0, so this equilibrium is never reached.
C is the old equilibrium on D0. Demand has fallen to D1, so firms no longer want this many workers at W0.
Rules that make firing costly also make firms wary of hiring
Many European countries require months of notice before a lay-off and large severance payments. Such laws discourage firing, but when firms know it will be hard to lay workers off, they also become hesitant about hiring in the first place. Higher unemployment in many of those countries, even in years of solid growth, has been attributed to such rules. In the United States, the growth of temporary agency work has probably helped to lower unemployment, since a temporary job is often a step to a permanent one.
The Taylor Review found flexibility supports jobs but can run one way
The Taylor Review of Modern Working Practices, published by the government in 2017, found that flexibility had helped firms respond to changing market conditions and had supported record employment, letting people fit work around study or caring. It also heard repeatedly that flexibility was not reciprocated: some workers had to be available at very short notice with no guarantee of work, which made it hard to manage bills or get a mortgage.
Most zero-hours workers do not want more hours, but a large minority do
In April to June 2026, 1.23 million people in the UK, 3.6 per cent of everyone in work, said their main job was on a zero-hours contract. Of them, 59 per cent did not want more hours. But 29 per cent were underemployed, wanting more hours, against 7 per cent of other workers.
Check yourself
Of people on zero-hours contracts in April to June 2026, 59 per cent did not want more hours and 29 per cent did. Which conclusion do these figures support?
Give both sides, then a judgement. For: a fall in demand costs fewer jobs, backed by the European contrast or the Taylor Review. Against: insecurity and too few hours, backed by the zero-hours figures. Then name what it turns on: whether workers choose the flexibility or have it imposed.
Check yourself
Three of these are numerical flexibility. Which one is functional flexibility?
Exam question
Assess the view that a more flexible labour market benefits workers as well as firms. [5]
Flexible wages and easier hiring mean a fall in demand costs fewer jobs, and rules that make firing costly make firms slow to hire; the Taylor Review found flexibility had supported record UK employment. But flexibility can run one way: in April to June 2026, 29 per cent of people on zero-hours contracts wanted more hours, against 7 per cent of other workers. Whether workers gain depends on whether the flexibility suits them or is imposed on them.
One mark for the gain in employment and one for evidence on it; one for the cost to workers and one for evidence on it; one for a judgement naming what the answer depends on. One side only earns two.
Labour market flexibility covers numbers, tasks and wages. A flexible wage lets a fall in demand cut pay rather than jobs, and costly firing rules make firms wary of hiring. The Taylor Review found flexibility had supported record UK employment, but that for some workers it ran one way, on call with no guaranteed work. What the answer turns on is whom the flexibility serves.