Learn › Economic theory › Firms and competition

Firms and competition

Is competition policy worth it?

Weigh the case each way on breaking up a large firm

Specification: AQA 4.1.5.6, 4.1.8.7 Edexcel 3.4.5, 3.6.1

Key terms
Competition policy
Competition policy is the body of law that promotes competition between firms, including the power to block certain mergers and, in some cases, to break up large firms.
Price cap regulation
Price cap regulation is where a regulator sets the price that a firm with market power can charge over the next few years.

Economists object that a monopoly supplies too little

Most people criticise monopolies for charging too high a price. What economists object to is that they do not supply enough output to be allocatively efficient. At its profit-maximising output a monopoly's price is always above marginal cost, so buyers value one more unit at more than it would cost to make, and it goes unmade. Consumers get a lower quantity at a higher price than a competitive market would give them.

A monopoly's output and priceVertical axis: Price and cost. Horizontal axis: Quantity. D = AR: a downward-sloping line. MR: a downward-sloping line. MC: an upward-sloping line. MR meets MC, at quantity Qm. A point at price Pm. D = AR meets MC, at price P* and quantity Q*. Shaded area DWL: deadweight loss.DWLQmPmQ*P*D = ARMRMC
The monopoly makes Qm, where MR = MC, and charges Pm, read off the demand curve, well above marginal cost. A competitive market would produce Q*, where price equals marginal cost. The shaded area DWL, the amount by which buyers value the units between Qm and Q* above what they would cost to make, is the deadweight loss: those units are never made.

A firm with no rivals to fear may stop trying

Once a barrier to entry is in place, a monopoly can keep producing the same old products in the same old way and still earn a healthy profit. John Hicks, who later won the Nobel Prize, wrote in 1935: "The best of all monopoly profits is a quiet life." The incentive runs the other way too: firms strive for new inventions precisely because they hope to win monopoly profits for a few years.

Check yourself

Why do economists say a monopoly is allocatively inefficient?

Splitting a firm with large economies of scale raises its costs

Where average cost falls across the whole range the market demands, one firm supplies it more cheaply than two. In a textbook model of a natural monopoly, cutting the firm in half raises average cost by about a quarter, and customers pay for it. The split may not even last: one half may grow, undercut the other and drive it out, or the two may find quiet ways to coordinate and keep prices high.

Check yourself

Regulators split a natural monopoly into two equal firms. What does the model predict?

The answer turns on how large the economies of scale are

Where a firm is a natural monopoly, breaking it up raises costs, so the usual remedy is to regulate its price instead. Setting price at average cost lets the firm cover its costs and earn a normal profit, but gives it little reason to cut them, so regulators moved to price caps set for several years, under which a firm keeps the profit from cutting costs faster than the cap. Where economies of scale are small, rivals can supply as cheaply, so restoring competition removes the inefficiency at little cost.

Exam tip

In a UK answer, name the law: the Competition Act 1998 bans cartels and abuse of a dominant position, and the Competition and Markets Authority can block mergers and, after a market investigation, require a firm to sell parts of its business. Weigh allocative inefficiency and the quiet life against lost economies of scale, then judge whether the firm's economies of scale are large relative to the market.

Check yourself

This monopoly produces where MR = MC. Which area is lost to society because it produces less than a competitive market would?

A monopoly with three shaded areasVertical axis: Price and cost. Horizontal axis: Quantity. D = AR: a downward-sloping line. MR: a downward-sloping line. MC: an upward-sloping line. MR meets MC. D = AR meets MC. Shaded area A. Shaded area B. Shaded area C.ABCD = ARMRMC

Exam question

Assess whether the Competition and Markets Authority should break up a firm with a very large share of its market. [8]

What to take away

A monopoly prices above marginal cost, so it produces too little, and without rivals it may settle for a quiet life. Breaking it up restores competition. But where economies of scale are large, a split raises average cost, and the pieces may drift back to dominance or coordination. So breaking up a large firm is worth it when rivals could supply as cheaply; for a natural monopoly, capping its price is usually the better remedy.