Ministers choose most government spending, but some pressures build whoever is in office
Most UK public spending is planned. The Treasury sets departments' budgets in Spending Reviews and the Chancellor can change them in a Budget, so more nurses or a new railway line is a choice ministers make. Other pressures build up year after year. The OBR points to an ageing population and the rising cost of healthcare, which push spending on the NHS up, and to pressure on the UK and other European countries to raise defence spending to its highest level since the end of the Cold War.
The trade cycle pulls public spending up in a slump and down in a boom
When the economy slows, more people lose their jobs and claim benefits, so public spending rises with no new decision; in a boom it falls back. Those benefits are transfers, not G: the government buys nothing with them, and they reach aggregate demand only when claimants spend them, as consumption. G itself moves with the cycle when the government chooses to move it, spending more on goods, services and building projects in a recession, and holding back when demand runs ahead of what the economy can produce.
Check yourself
A recession pushes up unemployment, and many more people claim Universal Credit. What happens to G, government spending in aggregate demand?
Take a guess
The government decides to spend an extra £20 billion on new hospitals and schools. What do you think happens to the aggregate demand curve?
Government purchases are one of the four parts of aggregate demand, so buying more of them raises spending at every price level and moves the whole curve right. The price level did not cause the change, so it is a shift, not a movement.
Higher government purchases shift AD to the right at every price level
Government spending is one component of aggregate demand, AD = C + I + G + (X − M). When the government orders more warships or builds more schools, total spending is higher whatever the price level, so the whole AD curve shifts right, from AD0 to AD1. The new equilibrium has more real GDP and a higher price level. Lower government spending does the reverse and shifts AD to the left. A change in G always shifts the curve; only a change in the price level moves the economy along it.
1 of 2
BeforeAD0 meets SRAS at E0, with price level P0 and real GDP Y0.
A rise in G moves the whole AD curve right, from AD0 to AD1, and the economy from E0 to E1.
Check yourself
To cut its borrowing, the government reduces spending on new roads and school buildings. Which way does the AD curve move?
Spare capacity decides whether a rise in G buys output or higher prices
In a recession, output is far below potential GDP and there are idle workers and machines. Firms meet the extra government orders by producing more, so the rightward shift in AD mostly raises real GDP and the price level barely moves. When the economy is already close to full capacity, firms cannot produce much more. The same shift then mostly pushes up wages and prices, with little gain in output. A rise in G suits a recession; in an overheating economy, a cut in G is one fiscal response.
1 of 2
Spare capacityFar below capacity, SRAS is flat. AD shifts from AD0 to AD1, so real GDP rises a long way, from Y0 to Y1, and the price level only a little, from P0 to P1.
The same rightward shift in AD buys mostly output where SRAS is flat and mostly higher prices where it is steep.
Key terms
Government spending
Government spending is the government's purchases of goods or services produced in the economy, such as a new fighter jet, a road or a school.
Transfer payment
A transfer payment is money the government pays to people, such as a pension or a benefit, without receiving any good or service in return.
Common mistake
If the government spends £10 billion more, doesn't AD shift by exactly £10 billion?
Not usually. The £10 billion becomes income for the firms and workers who supply the government, and they spend part of it, which becomes someone else's income, so the multiplier makes the final shift larger than the first rise in G. Pulling the other way, if the government borrows the money, interest rates can rise and squeeze private investment, so part of the rise is crowded out. Weigh both when you judge the size of the effect.
Exam tip
Name the driver, then follow the chain: "in a recession the government brings forward spending on new schools, so G rises, AD shifts right from AD0 to AD1, and real GDP rises". Keep benefits out of G; they reach AD through consumption. To evaluate, say how much spare capacity there is, and whether extra borrowing could crowd out private investment.
Check yourself
The economy is close to full capacity, and the government raises its spending on defence equipment. What is the most likely result?
Exam question
Explain one reason why government spending might rise during a recession, and how the rise is likely to affect aggregate demand and real GDP. [4]
The government may use expansionary fiscal policy, bringing forward spending on projects such as schools and roads to support demand. Government spending is a component of AD, so AD shifts to the right. With spare capacity in a recession, firms can produce more, so real GDP rises with little rise in the price level, and the multiplier makes the rise larger than the first injection.
One mark for a reason (a choice to support demand, not the rise in benefits, which is not G), one for G as a component of AD, one for the rightward shift, and one for real GDP rising, developed through spare capacity or the multiplier.
What to take away
Government spending, G, is the government's purchases of goods and services; pensions and benefits are transfers, counted only when spent. It changes with fiscal policy, chosen in the Budget; with the trade cycle, when governments spend more in a slump; and with long-run pressures such as an ageing population. A rise in G shifts AD to the right and a cut shifts it left. With spare capacity the shift mostly raises real GDP; near full capacity it mostly raises the price level.