- Government failure
- Government failure is government intervention that itself results in an inefficient allocation of resources, such as a subsidy for a polluting good or regulation that causes shortages.
- Market failure
- Market failure is a situation where the free market, left to its own devices, is unable to achieve optimal economic efficiency.
Types of government failure
Can you name the four types of government failure the specifications list, and a fifth this page adds?
Each is a way an intervention meant to fix a market can leave resources worse allocated. The A-level specifications name the first four; the fifth, regulatory capture, is not on every specification but makes a strong evaluation point.
A distortion of price signals is when a tax, subsidy or price rule changes prices so that they no longer reflect true costs and benefits.
Can you think of an example?
A subsidy for producing a good that causes high levels of pollution keeps its price low, so buyers and firms are told to make and use more of it than society should.
Unintended consequences are effects of a policy that its makers did not plan, as people respond in unexpected ways that undermine the policy's intent.
Can you think of an example?
A rent cap meant to help renters leads landlords to take flats off the market, so fewer are rented. Those who cannot find a flat bear the cost, but nobody can say who they are.
An information gap is when the government lacks what it needs to know, such as the true external cost, and sets a policy at the wrong level.
Can you think of an example?
A government taxes plastic bags at 50p each to cut litter, guessing the damage. If the real damage is 10p a bag, the tax cuts bag use well below the social optimum.
Excessive administrative costs are when running an intervention costs more than the benefit it delivers, often because a tax-funded agency with no competitors has little pressure to cut costs.
Can you think of an example?
A grant scheme hands out £2 million a year but costs £3 million to run in staff, checks and paperwork. A firm with costs like that would lose customers to rivals; a government department has no rivals, so it carries on.
Regulatory capture is when the industry being regulated comes to exercise influence over its regulators, so the rules serve the industry rather than the public.
Can you think of an example?
A rail regulator hires its senior staff from the train companies, and relies on those companies for its figures. Over time its rules protect the companies' profits rather than passengers, who get higher fares and late trains.
Check yourself
A regulator sets pollution limits for an industry, then relaxes them after the industry's lobbyists help draft the rules. Which form of government failure is this?
A policy is judged against the market failure it was meant to fix
Markets sometimes fail, and government can play a useful role in fixing them, but government action is also imperfect. So the test is not whether a policy is flawless. It is whether the allocation of resources ends up better or worse than the market would have left it, weighing the strengths and weaknesses of both real markets and real governments.
Check yourself
A government subsidises bus fares to cut traffic congestion. Which outcome would make the subsidy a government failure?
Isn't every policy that leaves some of the problem unsolved a government failure?
No. A pollution tax that cuts emissions most of the way to the social optimum has improved the allocation of resources, even though some welfare loss remains. Government failure means the intervention itself goes wrong and leaves resources worse allocated than the market it was meant to correct.
Name the type, give the mechanism, and say who loses. "Regulatory capture: the industry shaped the rules, so pollution stayed above the optimum" earns what "the government got it wrong" cannot. In evaluation, weigh the government failure against the market failure it was meant to fix, and say which is larger.
Check yourself
Three of these are forms of government failure. Which one is a market failure?
Exam question
Explain two reasons why government intervention to correct a market failure may lead to government failure. [4]
First, regulatory capture: the firms being regulated lobby hard because each stands to lose a lot, so rules are written in their interest rather than society's. Second, poor information: the government may not know the size of the external cost, so a tax set at the wrong level over- or under-corrects and the allocation of resources can end up worse.
Two marks for each reason: one for naming it and one for the mechanism that makes resources worse allocated. Unintended consequences of a price control or excessive administrative costs would also earn full marks with their mechanism.
Government failure is intervention that itself leaves resources worse allocated. The specifications name four forms: distortion of price signals, unintended consequences, information gaps and excessive administrative costs, and regulatory capture adds a fifth. Markets sometimes fail and government can help fix them, but its action is imperfect too, so weigh real markets against real governments rather than an ideal version of either.