- Dynamic efficiency
- Dynamic efficiency is the rate at which firms reduce their real costs, or improve their product quality, over time through new technologies or processes.
- Static efficiency
- Static efficiency is how much output can be produced from a given stock of resources at a certain point in time.
Kinds of innovation
Can you name the two kinds of innovation that make a firm dynamically efficient?
Innovation changes either how a product is made or the product itself.
Process innovation is a new or better way of making an existing product, so that each unit takes fewer resources to produce.
Can you think of an example?
A bakery chain installs a faster, automated oven line. The loaves are the same, but each takes fewer hours of work and less energy, so the cost per loaf falls.
Product innovation is the creation of a new or improved good or service that buyers value more than what came before.
Can you think of an example?
A phone maker adds a longer-lasting battery and a better camera at the old price, so buyers get more for their money.
Dynamic efficiency is judged over years, not at a single moment
Static efficiency looks at one point in time: whether a firm produces at its lowest possible average cost (productive efficiency), and whether price equals marginal cost (allocative efficiency). Dynamic efficiency asks how fast the firm cuts its real costs or improves its products over time. A firm can be productively efficient this year and still fall behind, if its methods never change while a rival invests in new technology.
Check yourself
A steelworks has produced at its lowest possible average cost for ten years, with the same furnaces and the same methods throughout. Which statement fits?
Innovation needs a prospect of profit to pay for it
Innovation takes time and resources. If rivals can copy a new drug without bearing the cost of the research behind it, they can undercut its price, so many firms would choose not to invest at all. Patents answer this with a temporary monopoly. An innovative firm expects a temporary edge over its competitors, and above-normal profits until they catch up. That profit rewards the innovation and can pay for the next round of research.
Competition pushes firms to innovate, up to a point
Under competition, firms innovate to gain a cost advantage, to make their products different or to bring new products to the market, while a monopoly with no rivals to fear can make the same old products in the same old way and still earn a healthy profit. Yet the reward for innovating comes from the market power an innovation brings. Studying UK firms, Aghion and colleagues found an inverted U: where competition starts out limited, more of it brings more innovation, but beyond a certain point more competition may reduce it.
Check yourself
Aghion and colleagues found an inverted-U shape between competition and innovation in UK firms. What does that shape say?
Isn't a monopoly always less efficient than a perfectly competitive market?
Not over time. At a single moment it is allocatively inefficient: it prices above marginal cost and supplies too little. But firms may strive for new inventions because they want to become monopolies and earn high profits, at least until the competition catches up. Perfect competition assumes away new technology, and in the long run leaves each firm only normal profit, with little over for research. A monopoly that spends its supernormal profit on new methods and products can be statically inefficient and dynamically efficient.
To evaluate a monopoly or a merger, set dynamic efficiency against static inefficiency. Say where the supernormal profit goes: into research and new methods, or into dividends and a quiet life. Then use the case's evidence, such as spending on research or real prices falling over time, to judge which.
Check yourself
Three of these are signs of dynamic efficiency. Which one is not?
Exam question
Explain how supernormal profit may allow a monopoly to be more dynamically efficient than a firm in perfect competition. [4]
Barriers to entry let a monopoly keep supernormal profit in the long run, and it can spend that profit on research and new capital, cutting its real costs or improving its products over time. A firm in perfect competition earns only normal profit in the long run, so it has little to spend on research, and rivals could copy an innovation quickly, which cuts the reward for trying.
Two marks for each side: one for the point and one for the link to dynamic efficiency. Full marks need the chain from profit to research to lower costs or better products, not just "more money".
Dynamic efficiency is the rate at which firms reduce their real costs or improve their product quality over time, through process and product innovation; static efficiency is judged at one point in time. Competition pushes firms to innovate, but the reward comes from the market power a successful innovation brings, so a monopoly that spends its supernormal profit on research can be dynamically efficient.