Learn › Economic theory › Policy and the financial sector

Policy and the financial sector

Does the size of the state matter?

Explain how the share of national income the state spends can help or harm growth, living standards and equality

Specification: AQA 4.2.5.1 Edexcel 4.5.1

Key terms
Size of the state
The size of the state is how much the public sector spends, on services, investment, transfers and debt interest, measured as a share of national income.
Budget deficit
A budget deficit is the amount by which government spending exceeds the money it receives in taxes in a given year.

The UK state spends over two-fifths of national income

In its March 2026 forecast the OBR expected the public sector to spend £1,368 billion in 2025-26, 44.8 per cent of national income, and to raise 40.4 per cent in receipts. On OECD figures for 2025, UK spending is slightly above the average of other industrial countries: more than the United States and Japan, much less than Italy or France.

The share grows when spending on pensions and health rises faster than the economy, and in recessions, when output falls while spending on benefits rises.

Spending on skills and infrastructure can raise output and equality together

Spending on roads, water systems, education and research can raise an economy's output and productivity: firms with reliable roads and electricity produce more, and a well-educated workforce is a powerful source of growth.

Some of this spending also narrows inequality. Free schooling is worth more to children from low-income families than their families pay in tax, yet it also supplies tomorrow's skilled workers, so equality and growth can rise together. Services such as the NHS also raise living standards directly, whatever their effect on measured growth.

Check yourself

A government raises spending on free schooling in its poorest areas. On the case for a larger state, why might this raise output as well as equality?

Paying for a large state can crowd out investment and blunt incentives

Spending has to be paid for. Borrowing can soak up savings that firms would have invested, and higher household taxes can cut private saving to similar effect. Very high taxes on the rich, and benefits withdrawn as people earn more, can discourage work and enterprise.

Public investment also lacks the discipline of the market. A firm that invests badly loses money; a government may build what is politically popular rather than what pays, or pay too much for it.

Check yourself

Which of these is an argument that a larger state can slow growth?

The answer depends on where an economy sits on the trade-off

One view draws a straight trade-off: every move towards equality costs output. Another says the trade-off first slopes up, as spending such as schooling raises both, then flattens, since high-income countries with similar incomes have different levels of inequality, and falls only when the push for equality goes far enough to blunt incentives. On that view, what the state buys and how far it has gone matter more than its size alone.

Output and equality: a trade-off that is not a straight lineVertical axis: Economic output. Horizontal axis: Equality. Trade-off: a hump-shaped curve.Trade-offCDEF
Output rises with equality from C to D, barely changes from D to E, and falls from E to F.
Exam tip

Judge by what the spending buys and how it is paid for, not by the share alone. Name a channel, such as crowding out or incentives, then a condition, such as the quality of public investment. Quote the UK share of national income with its source and year.

Check yourself

Each point marks a possible mix of equality and output. At which point would a further push for equality cost the most output?

Output and equalityVertical axis: Economic output. Horizontal axis: Equality. Trade-off: a hump-shaped curve.Trade-offPQR

Exam question

Evaluate the view that a larger state harms economic growth. [8]

What to take away

The UK public sector spends 44.8 per cent of national income, forecast for 2025-26, slightly above the industrial-country average. Spending on infrastructure, schooling and research can raise productivity, and some of it raises equality and output together. Paying for a large state can crowd out investment and blunt incentives, and public projects lack market discipline. What the state buys, and how it pays, matter more than its size alone.