- Crowding out
- Crowding out is when government borrowing soaks up available savings and leaves less financial capital for private firms to invest in physical capital.
- Ricardian equivalence
- Ricardian equivalence is the theory that households save more when the government borrows, expecting higher taxes later, so total saving is unchanged.
What changes the deficit and the debt
Can you name four things that change the size of the deficit and the national debt?
Each changes how much the government borrows in a year.
The state of the economy sets tax receipts and welfare spending: a recession widens the deficit and a boom narrows it.
Can you think of an example?
In a recession VAT and income tax receipts fall and Universal Credit claims rise, with no change in policy.
Tax and spending decisions, such as cutting a tax or spending more on health, change the deficit at any level of activity.
Can you think of an example?
A Budget cuts the basic rate of income tax and raises NHS spending: both add to borrowing in any year.
An ageing population means more people drawing pensions and health care for each person of working age paying tax.
Can you think of an example?
Spending on state pensions and the NHS grows faster than income tax as more people pass pension age.
Crises such as wars and pandemics raise spending and cut receipts at once, adding large sums to the debt quickly.
Can you think of an example?
In the Covid pandemic the state paid furloughed workers' wages as receipts fell, and borrowing hit a post-war record.
Debt interest is spending that buys no public service
Every pound borrowed carries interest. In its March 2026 forecast the OBR expected net interest on the national debt to cost £110 billion in 2025-26, and about 9 per cent of receipts other than interest across the forecast: money that cannot go on schools, the NHS or tax cuts, and a bill that rises with interest rates.
Borrowing also passes part of the cost forward: the spending happens now, and later taxpayers pay the interest.
Heavy borrowing can raise interest rates and crowd out investment
A larger deficit adds to the demand for loanable funds. If saving stays the same, the interest rate rises and firms borrow less to invest. A survey of US studies found that a rise in the deficit of 1 per cent of GDP raised interest rates by 0.5 to 1.0 percentage points, other things equal.
Very large deficits can also make lenders fear they will not be repaid, so they want a higher rate to hold the debt, and credit rating agencies may lower their grade for its bonds.
BeforeSavers supply S and borrowers demand D0, so the interest rate is R0.
Check yourself
The government cuts its borrowing sharply and nothing else changes. Which way does the demand for loanable funds move?
Borrowing for investment, or in a slump, does less harm
Borrowing can pay for roads, schools and research that raise productivity for years, if the projects are well chosen.
Crowding out is not automatic either. In the 2008-09 recession firms had little reason to invest and central banks cut rates, so interest rates fell while government borrowing soared. And it is unclear whether high debt slows growth or slow growth raises debt.
The gap between the interest rate and growth sets the debt's path
The OBR calls the gap between the interest rate on government debt and nominal GDP growth the growth-corrected interest rate, or r minus g, a key determinant of debt as a share of GDP. With r below g the ratio can fall while the government still borrows. The UK's r minus g was negative for most of the ten years to 2023. In November 2023 the OBR forecast it at 1.4 per cent in the medium term; with r above g, a primary surplus, a surplus before interest, is needed to stop the ratio rising.
Check yourself
Debt is 100 per cent of GDP. The budget balances before interest, so the only new borrowing is the interest, at 3 per cent of the debt. Nominal GDP grows by 5 per cent. What is the debt-to-GDP ratio after one year, in per cent, to one decimal place?
98.1
The debt grows by the interest, from 100 to 103, and GDP grows from 100 to 105. 103 ÷ 105 × 100 = 98.1 per cent. With r below g the ratio falls with no surplus at all.
Weigh the debt, not just its costs: name what it paid for, compare the interest rate with the growth rate, and say whether the economy has spare capacity, since crowding out needs scarce savings. A judgement naming the conditions under which debt harms growth earns the evaluation marks.
Check yourself
In a deep recession interest rates are low and firms are cutting investment. The government borrows heavily. What does the evidence from 2008-09 suggest about crowding out?
Exam question
Evaluate the view that a large national debt is always harmful to an economy. [8]
Debt costs money every year: the UK's net interest bill was forecast at £110 billion for 2025-26, which cannot fund services, and later taxpayers pay it. Heavy borrowing can raise interest rates and crowd out private investment, and very large deficits can shake lenders' confidence. But deficits can run for decades while the debt ratio falls if growth exceeds the interest rate, borrowing for investment can raise future output, and in a slump crowding out is small. So debt is most likely to harm when r exceeds g, when it funds day-to-day spending, and when savings are scarce; it is not always harmful.
Up to four marks for the costs (interest, crowding out, confidence, the burden on later taxpayers), up to four for evaluation: r against g, what the borrowing paid for, spare capacity, and a judgement on whether the harm follows in every case.
A large debt costs interest every year, paid by later taxpayers, and heavy borrowing can raise interest rates and crowd out investment. But the debt ratio falls, even with deficits, while the debt grows more slowly than GDP; borrowing can fund investment; and crowding out is small in a slump. The answer turns on r against g, what the borrowing bought, and whether savings are scarce.