Learn › Economic theory › Work and what it pays

Work and what it pays

Does discrimination survive a competitive market?

Weigh the case each way on labour-market discrimination

Specification: AQA 4.1.6.7

Key terms
Labour market discrimination
Labour market discrimination arises when workers with the same education, experience and expertise receive different pay or job opportunities because of their race or gender.
Earnings gap
An earnings gap is a difference between the average wages of two groups, which on its own does not prove discrimination.

Becker argued that competition makes discrimination costly

Gary Becker, who won the Nobel Prize in economics in 1992, was one of the first to analyse discrimination in economic terms. If some employers refuse to pay women or minority workers a wage based on their productivity, other profit-seeking employers can hire those workers. In a competitive market, a firm that cares more about profit than prejudice has an incentive to hire and promote on economic grounds alone.

Check yourself

On Becker's argument, why might competition reduce discrimination by employers?

Becker also showed why discrimination can persist

Prejudice can come from customers and co-workers as well as from managers. A manager with no prejudice, whose workers or customers are prejudiced, may find that treating everyone fairly hurts morale or drives customers away, so that not discriminating reduces the firm's profits. Market forces alone are unlikely to overwhelm strong social attitudes, and history suggests they will not eliminate discrimination on their own.

Field experiments find discrimination that a raw gap cannot show

One study in the United States answered job advertisements with invented CVs carrying either typically white or typically African American names, and found that the white names received 50 per cent more calls to interview. A 2007 US Department of Labor study comparing men and women with similar education, experience and occupation found a gender wage gap of only 5 per cent, which could be discrimination or differences it did not capture.

Check yourself

Which finding would come closest to showing labour market discrimination rather than a difference in productivity?

The UK gender pay gap is real and is not a measure of equal pay

In April 2025 the median hourly pay of women working full-time in the UK was 6.9 per cent below men's, and the gap has fallen by more than a quarter over the last decade. The ONS stresses that this is a measure across all jobs, not of the difference in pay between men and women doing the same job, so it cannot say on its own how much of the gap is discrimination.

Exam tip

Give Becker's argument, then the reasons it fails, then the evidence, and close with a judgement. Competition punishes an employer's own prejudice; it does much less against prejudice among customers or co-workers, and nothing against discrimination that happens before people reach the labour market. Never treat a raw pay gap as proof of discrimination on its own.

Check yourself

The ONS reports that women working full-time in the UK earn a median hourly wage 6.9 per cent below men's. What does that figure measure?

Exam question

Assess the view that competition in labour markets will remove discrimination. [8]

What to take away

Labour market discrimination is paying equally qualified workers differently because of race or gender, and an earnings gap on its own does not prove it. Becker argued that competition penalises an employer's prejudice, because rivals can hire the workers it underpays. He also showed why discrimination persists where customers and co-workers are prejudiced. A field experiment with invented CVs has found it persisting, so market forces alone are unlikely to eliminate it.