In the short run a firm adds workers to capital it cannot change
The short run is the period during which at least some factors of production are fixed. A bakery has one set of ovens until it can buy more, so to make more bread it can only add workers and flour. At first each extra worker adds more than the one before: a second baker frees the first from serving, answering the phone and sweeping, so both can specialise. The marginal product of labour, the extra output of one more worker, rises.
RisingUp to L1 workers, each one adds more output than the last: they divide up the tasks.
Sooner or later each extra worker adds less than the last
The gains from specialisation run out. With the ovens fixed, a fifth or sixth baker has less equipment to work with and spends time waiting for an oven to come free. Total output still rises, but by less with each worker added. In the end workers may get in each other's way and output can even fall. The cause is the fixed factor: each extra unit of the variable input has less of it to work with, so it contributes less to overall production.
Check yourself
A car wash with one set of equipment washes 30 cars an hour with three workers and 36 cars an hour with four. What is the marginal product of the fourth worker, in cars an hour?
6
Marginal product is the change in total output from one more worker: 36 cars minus 30 cars is 6 cars an hour. It is not the average, 36 divided by 4, which is 9.
Each extra worker now adds less output than the one before, and every worker is paid the same wage. What do you think happens to the cost of making one more car wash?
The wage per worker is the same, but each worker now produces fewer extra units. So each extra unit of output needs more labour time, and its cost rises.
Falling marginal product makes marginal cost rise
If every worker costs the same wage, the cost of an extra unit of output depends on how much that worker adds. While marginal product rises, each extra unit takes less labour, so marginal cost falls. Once diminishing returns set in, each extra unit takes more labour, so marginal cost rises and total cost starts rising more rapidly. The marginal cost curve is a mirror of the marginal product curve: its lowest point comes at the output where marginal product is highest.
Check yourself
A firm's marginal cost is rising as output increases in the short run. What is the most likely cause?
Rising marginal cost bends average cost into a U
Average variable cost follows marginal cost with a lag: while the next unit costs less than the average so far it pulls the average down, and once it costs more it pulls the average up. So marginal cost cuts average variable cost at its lowest point. Average total cost falls at first as fixed costs are spread over more output, then rises once diminishing returns push variable costs up faster than output. So average cost curves in the short run are U-shaped.
- Diminishing marginal returns
- Diminishing marginal returns occur when adding more of a variable input to a fixed input eventually makes each extra unit of the variable input add less to output.
- Diseconomies of scale
- Diseconomies of scale occur when a firm's average costs rise as the level of output and the scale of the firm rise in the long run.
The parts of the law of diminishing returns
Can you name the three ideas the law of diminishing marginal returns is built from?
The law only holds when some inputs are fixed, so it needs all three.
A fixed input is one that cannot easily be increased or decreased in a short period of time, such as a building on a lease.
Can you think of an example?
A café has signed a five-year lease on its premises. However busy it gets, it cannot add floor space until the lease ends.
A variable input is one that can easily be increased or decreased in a short period of time, such as ingredients or staff hours.
Can you think of an example?
The same café can order more milk with one phone call, or ask its part-time staff to work an extra shift on Saturday.
Marginal product is the additional output of one more worker, the change in total product divided by the change in labour.
Can you think of an example?
Two baristas serve 60 customers an hour and three serve 75. The third barista's marginal product is 15 customers an hour.
Doesn't diminishing returns mean the firm's output falls?
No. Diminishing marginal returns means each extra worker adds less than the one before, not that output falls. Total output keeps rising as long as marginal product is above zero. Take lumberjacks sharing one two-person saw who cut 10, 12 and then 13 trees an hour as a second, third and fourth worker join: marginal product falls from 6 to 2 to 1, but total output still rises. Only when marginal product turns negative does total output fall.
Write the chain in order, one link per sentence: capital is fixed in the short run; extra workers each add less output; so each extra unit of output needs more labour; so marginal cost rises. Then link MC to the averages: MC cuts AVC and ATC at their lowest points. Never use economies or diseconomies of scale to explain a short-run curve.
Check yourself
Which point marks the output at which diminishing marginal returns set in?
Yes. A is the lowest point of marginal cost. Beyond it each extra unit needs more labour than the last, because marginal product is falling.
B is the lowest point of average variable cost. Marginal cost has already been rising for a while before it pulls the average up here.
C is the lowest point of average total cost. Diminishing returns set in earlier; ATC keeps falling until MC climbs above it.
Exam question
Explain why a firm's short-run marginal cost curve eventually slopes upwards. [4]
In the short run at least one factor, such as capital, is fixed. As the firm adds more of a variable factor such as labour, each extra worker has less capital to work with, so after a point marginal product falls: diminishing marginal returns. With the wage unchanged, each extra unit of output then needs more labour and so costs more to make, so marginal cost rises.
One mark for a fixed factor in the short run, one for falling marginal product as more of the variable factor is added, one for naming diminishing marginal returns, and one for the link: more labour per extra unit means a higher marginal cost.
In the short run at least one factor of production is fixed. Adding workers to it raises marginal product at first, as they specialise, but sooner or later each extra worker adds less than the last: diminishing marginal returns. Each extra unit of output then needs more labour, so marginal cost rises, and it pulls average variable and average total cost up after their lowest points. That gives short-run cost curves their U shape.