- Ceteris paribus
- Ceteris paribus is the assumption that no relevant economic factors other than the one being studied are changing; the Latin means “other things being equal”.
- Economic model
- An economic model is a simplified representation of how two or more variables interact with each other.
A model strips a problem down to the variables that matter
Economists analyse problems with theories built on particular assumptions about how people behave. A theory, or model, is a simplified representation of how two or more variables interact. It takes a complex, real-world issue and cuts it down to its essentials: simple enough to understand, while complex enough to capture the key features of the situation.
The circular flow is an example. It shows the whole economy as just two groups, households and firms, meeting in two markets, one for goods and services and one for labour. Much is left out, and details such as government and trade can be added when they are needed.
Economics studies people, so it cannot test its models in a laboratory
Economics is a social science: it studies how people, firms and governments choose to use scarce resources. Like a natural science, it builds theories and tests them against evidence. A chemist can repeat an experiment with one thing changed and everything else held fixed. An economist cannot re-run the UK economy with only interest rates altered. Millions of other things move at the same time, and people change how they act when they learn something new, such as a forecast that prices will rise. So economists hold other things equal in their reasoning, because they cannot hold them equal in a laboratory.
Check yourself
Why do economists rely on the ceteris paribus assumption more than a chemist does?
Economists change one factor at a time and then combine the results
A demand or supply curve is a relationship between two variables, price and quantity, drawn on the assumption that nothing else relevant changes. If other things are not held equal, the laws of demand and supply will not necessarily hold. Because each curve is drawn with income and tastes held fixed, a change in either shifts the whole curve instead of moving along it.
When several things change at once, say the price rises and incomes fall, the changes are examined one at a time. A higher price reduces the quantity bought, with income held constant. Lower income reduces it too, with price held constant. Combined, the quantity falls for two reasons.
Check yourself
Three of these statements use the ceteris paribus assumption correctly. Which one does not?
If other things are never equal in real life, doesn't that make ceteris paribus useless?
No. The assumption does not claim that nothing else changes. It is a way of separating causes, so that the effect of each can be traced before they are added together. A forecast that a tax rise will cut smoking, ceteris paribus, stays useful even if incomes also rise that year: it tells you the direction of the tax's effect, and the income effect can be worked out and combined with it.
Write "ceteris paribus" or "other things being equal" when you state a single cause and its effect, and mean it: name the one factor that changes. In evaluation, name another factor that is unlikely to stay equal, such as incomes during a recession, and say how it could change the outcome.
Check yourself
An economist predicts that a tax on sugary drinks will cut the quantity bought, ceteris paribus. The tax starts in a heatwave summer and the quantity bought rises. What follows?
Exam question
Explain why economists use the ceteris paribus assumption when building models. [4]
Economics is a social science, so it cannot run controlled experiments on a whole economy: many factors change at once and people react to what they learn. A model simplifies by isolating a relationship between two variables, such as price and quantity demanded. Assuming ceteris paribus holds every other factor fixed, so the effect of one change can be traced; several changes are then analysed one at a time and combined.
One mark for defining ceteris paribus as holding other factors constant; one for the lack of controlled experiments in a social science; one for models isolating a relationship; one for tracing one effect at a time and combining them. A definition alone earns one mark.
Economics is a social science. It builds models, simplified representations of how a few variables interact, and tests them against evidence, but it cannot hold an economy still in a laboratory. Ceteris paribus, "other things being equal", is the assumption that only the factor being studied changes. It lets economists trace one cause at a time, then combine the effects when several things change at once. Without it, the laws of demand and supply do not necessarily hold.