- Balanced budget
- A balanced budget is one where government spending and tax revenues are equal, so the government has no gap to cover by borrowing.
- Budget deficit
- A budget deficit is the gap the government must borrow to cover when its total spending in a year is higher than its total receipts.
One measure for each of the three objectives
Can you name the measure that goes with each of these three objectives?
Each objective is judged by a number tracked from year to year.
The deficit as a share of GDP is public sector net borrowing in a year divided by nominal GDP, which scales borrowing to the size of the economy.
Can you think of an example?
A government borrows £60 billion in a year when nominal GDP is £2,400 billion: a deficit of 2.5 per cent of GDP. A balanced budget would show zero.
Greenhouse gas emissions are the carbon dioxide and other gases that warm the climate, released in a year by a country's homes, firms and transport.
Can you think of an example?
A country emits 400 million tonnes of greenhouse gases one year and 380 million tonnes the next, a fall of 5 per cent. Net zero means whatever is still emitted is balanced by gases taken out of the atmosphere.
The Gini coefficient is a summary of income inequality running from zero, where income is shared equally among everyone, to one, where one person has it all.
Can you think of an example?
After benefits for low-income households rise, the Gini falls from 0.36 to 0.33: income is shared more equally than before.
Pollution is a cost the market leaves out, so the government steps in
Pollution is a negative externality. A firm counts its own costs of production, but the costs of its pollution pass on to people outside the sale who have no voice in it. Left alone, the market makes too much of any good whose production pollutes. Protecting the environment means correcting that, so growth does not run down the air, water and climate that future output depends on. The UK has a legal target of net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, and progress is judged against it.
Check yourself
A steelworks pours waste into a river used by anglers and by a water company downstream. Why does the market alone produce too much steel?
The aim is fairer incomes, not complete equality
No society should expect or want complete equality of income. People earn little in their first jobs, more in middle age and less after retiring, and they differ in how much they want to work. Inequality is most troubling when it comes from the circumstances a child grows up in rather than from effort or talent. So governments aim for greater equality, through taxes that take a larger share of higher incomes, benefits for lower incomes and wider access to education. Greater equality is a different goal from less poverty: if every income fell by the same proportion, more people would drop below a fixed poverty line while inequality stayed the same.
Check yourself
In a recession every household's income falls by 10 per cent. What happens to income inequality, as measured by the Gini coefficient?
Borrowing adds to a debt that carries interest, so governments aim to balance the budget
Each year's borrowing adds to the national debt, and interest on it is paid out of taxes that could otherwise fund schools or hospitals. A very large deficit can also push aggregate demand up and trigger inflation. Borrowing to invest is a different case, since a new railway can raise output for decades. So one of the UK's legislated fiscal rules targets the current budget, which counts all receipts and day-to-day spending but leaves out net investment.
Doesn't a balanced budget objective mean balancing the budget every single year?
No. In a recession tax revenue falls and spending on benefits rises on its own, so the deficit widens; in a boom it narrows. A rule forcing balance each and every year would stop these automatic stabilisers working and make recessions worse. So the objective is usually judged over the economic cycle, not in each calendar year.
For each objective give the measure and the reason. "A balanced budget, judged by public sector net borrowing as a share of GDP, so that debt interest does not crowd out other spending" earns what "not spending too much" cannot. For equality, name the Gini coefficient and say which way it should move; for the environment, name greenhouse gas emissions and the net zero target.
Check yourself
Public sector net borrowing is £75 billion in a year and nominal GDP is £2,500 billion. What is the deficit as a percentage of GDP?
%3
£75 billion ÷ £2,500 billion = 0.03, which is 3 per cent of GDP. Dividing GDP by borrowing instead gives 33.3, a ratio turned upside down.
Check yourself
A government's fiscal rule says the current budget must balance. Which of these can it still borrow to pay for?
Exam question
For a balanced budget and for greater income equality, state how a government measures progress and give one reason it pursues the objective. [4]
A balanced budget is measured by public sector net borrowing as a share of GDP; a government pursues it because borrowing adds to the national debt, and interest on the debt takes tax revenue away from other spending. Greater income equality is measured by the Gini coefficient, where a fall means income is shared more equally; a government pursues it because inequality that comes from the circumstances a child grows up in, rather than effort or talent, is widely seen as unfair.
One mark for each correct measure and one for each reason. Other reasons also earn the marks: a very large deficit can trigger inflation, and greater equality can widen opportunity for children from low-income families.
A balanced budget means spending equals tax revenue, aimed at over the cycle and tracked by borrowing as a share of GDP. Protecting the environment corrects pollution the market leaves out, judged by emissions against net zero. Greater income equality, not complete equality, is judged by a falling Gini coefficient.