- Automatic stabilisers
- Automatic stabilisers are tax and spending rules already in law that stimulate aggregate demand in a recession and hold it down in an inflationary boom.
- Discretionary fiscal policy
- Discretionary fiscal policy is a deliberate government decision that explicitly changes the level of taxes or government spending.
The main automatic stabilisers
Can you name the three main automatic stabilisers?
Two taxes and one kind of spending move with the economy on their own.
Income tax is based on personal income, so receipts rise automatically when pay rises in a boom and fall when pay falls in a recession.
Can you think of an example?
A factory worker on £30,000 a year loses her job and stops paying income tax. Her spending falls by less than her lost pay, because the tax she no longer pays cushions it.
Corporation tax is based on company profits, so receipts rise automatically as profits grow in a boom and fall as profits shrink in a recession.
Can you think of an example?
A large builder's profit falls from £40 million to £10 million in a recession. At a 25 per cent rate its tax bill drops from £10 million to £2.5 million, leaving it more cash to keep staff on.
Out-of-work benefits are paid under rules already in law to people who lose their jobs, so spending on them rises with unemployment and falls as people find work.
Can you think of an example?
In a recession a million more people claim Universal Credit as they lose their jobs. The payments put income back into households, and nobody had to vote for the extra spending.
Check yourself
In a boom, pay and company profits rise while tax rates stay the same. What happens to income tax and corporation tax receipts?
Stabilisers act at once and soften only part of the swing
Automatic stabilisers occur quickly: lower pay means less tax taken from pay packets straight away, and benefit spending rises as fast as people apply. They offset part of a swing in aggregate demand, not all or even most of it; one US estimate is about ten per cent of any initial movement in output. Like shock absorbers in a car, they reduce the worst bumps without removing them.
A stabiliser works with no new decision by the Chancellor
To tell a stabiliser from discretionary policy, ask whether anyone had to decide anything. VAT receipts falling because people spend less is automatic; the Chancellor cutting the VAT rate in a Budget is discretionary. A progressive income tax makes the stabiliser stronger, because tax takes a larger share of each extra pound as incomes rise and a smaller share as they fall.
Check yourself
Three of these are automatic stabilisers at work. Which one is discretionary fiscal policy?
If the deficit jumps in a recession, didn't the government choose to borrow more?
Not necessarily. Less activity means less tax, and more unemployment means more benefit spending, so the deficit widens with no new decision. Economists separate the two by estimating what the deficit would be if the economy were producing at potential GDP, which strips out the stabilisers. Whatever deficit is left does not go away as the economy recovers.
Name the stabiliser and give its mechanism in the direction the question asks. "In a recession incomes fall, so income tax receipts fall and households keep more of what they earn" earns the mark; "taxes act as a stabiliser" does not. Income tax and Universal Credit are the safest two to name.
Check yourself
Why do automatic stabilisers act faster than discretionary fiscal policy?
Exam question
Explain how two automatic stabilisers reduce the fall in aggregate demand during a recession. [4]
Income tax: as incomes fall, income tax receipts fall automatically, so disposable income falls by less and consumption is protected. Benefits: as unemployment rises, more people claim Universal Credit, so government spending rises and supports household incomes. Both are expansionary without any new decision, so aggregate demand falls by less than it otherwise would.
Two marks for each stabiliser: one for naming it and one for its mechanism in a recession. A stabiliser named without saying what happens to income or spending earns only the first mark.
Automatic stabilisers are tax and spending rules already in law. In a boom, rising incomes bring in more tax and falling unemployment cuts benefit spending, holding demand down. In a recession the same rules cut tax and raise benefit spending, holding demand up. They act at once and need no decision, but they soften only part of a swing, and they widen the deficit in a recession on their own.